|
Learn why even action-heavy scenes can benefit from slower-paced moments that give readers more time to process specific details.
In this post
Which pace is best for action-heavy scenes?
Action-heavy scenes include fights, chases, escapes, rescues, evacuations, survivals and disasters. The action is intense – characters react quickly, not just physically but also emotionally.
However, just because a lot’s going on doesn’t mean the entire scene needs to be consistently fast. In fact, there’s no absolute ‘best’ when it comes to which type of pacing should be used in an action scene. Instead, what matters is that each moment is paced appropriately. When faster pace works well
Faster-paced description pulls readers through that action in bursts. Look how in the example below, the prose doesn’t linger on any specific detail.
Faster pacing works brilliantly when authors want to move their characters through time and space quickly.
When slower pace works well
Slower-paced description introduces a moment of focus that interrupts that speed. Now look at how, in the example below, the reader is forced to home in on specific actions and details.
Slower-paced moments are great when characters need a beat to process something specific, and readers need to register that information.
Want to explore this further?
If you’re working on scene-level pacing in crime, mystery or thriller fiction, Line Editing for Crime, Mystery and Thriller Writers takes an even closer look at this topic. How to decide when a scene needs slowing down
Let’s take a closer look at those slow-down beats – and how they might enrich the prose without causing momentum to drag or even stall.
Below, I’ve focused on four different beats:
With all four, I’ve considered how giving those moments space can make the pressure a character is experiencing feel more significant and draw attention to the potential consequences. Beat 1: Notice a significant detail
In our everyday lives, none of us notices everything. Instead, we tend to notice what matters or what’s relevant in the moment. Perhaps I’m waiting for the kettle to boil. In that moment, I notice when it whistles but I don’t hear the birds tweeting or the background hum of the TV. It’s the same with characters moving through action-heavy scenes.
Let’s imagine our character is Tom, a field agent trying to reach a rendezvous point while being pursued by an enemy militia. The pace of the prose is fast, providing only minimal details of the terrain, direction and humidity – just enough to orient the reader as he runs through the jungle. But then an unexpected sound indicates that his pursuers may have got ahead of him. This is significant as it’s a potential obstacle that could scupper his escape and threaten his life. The pace can now slow so that Tom has space to pay attention. Now, the detail might become sharper. He’ll notice:
All these details are now significant and consequential, and so the narrative can take the time to report them. The description will slow the pace, but those details are relevant in that moment and affect how he’ll decide to proceed. That cause and effect ensures that momentum is preserved even though the pace has slowed. Beat 2: Process an emotion or realization
Let’s now imagine that Aki is an investigative journalist who’s trying to push through a crowd rushing to exit a building that’s being evacuated owing to a bomb threat. She must retrieve a crucial box of evidence from her office, and escape the building within the next nine minutes.
The scene’s pace is fast, with description that zips through the direction she takes, the rooms she passes, the steps she climbs, the distance she covers, and bursts of information about the time elapsed. And then as she passes a red door, a memory surfaces – something her friend and colleague said. The prose doesn’t need lengthy introspection at this point – the details of why this realization is important can be explored later – but it will benefit from having enough space on the page for the reader to register its significance. Perhaps a couple of fragments or short clipped sentences given their own line will be enough. These can report the words that she remembers, and that she stops in her tracks. The position on the page and the clipped sentence structure will stand out, and mirror the sharp shift in her thought pattern. For that moment, the pace will slow. With the emotional beat having landed, the prose can then return to the fast-paced action – what she now does and how she gets there based on what she realized. Beat 3: Assess and decide on a physical response
Sometimes a character in the middle of zippy action is confronted with options, for example:
Slowing the pace for a moment shows readers that the character’s mind is alert, that they’re having to think and make decisions even though they’re under pressure, and that they’re not on autopilot. Our investigative journalist has recovered the evidence from the building that was evacuated, and now has reason to suspect that her friend was involved in the bomb threat. That friend has now entered Aki’s home, threatened her and now they’re in the middle of a fight. The pace of the prose is fast, ripping through several kicks, swings, slaps and holds. Aki manages to grab a knife and holds it against her attacker’s throat. She has the upper hand. But now she has a dilemma – whether to cut and potentially kill her friend, thereby removing the threat to her own life, or find another way. The pace can slow for a moment to allow Aki to consider the conundrum. Again, it doesn’t require 200 words of introspection, but 30 words that give her space to assess and decide how she’s going to respond physically will give readers a deeper understanding of the kind of person she is, what her priorities are, how threatened she feels, and whether she’s able to physically take the life of someone she knows. As with the Tom example above, the slower-paced beat allows the reader to register what matters to Aki at a particular moment when the pressure created by the physical options open to her is so significant. Beat 4: Delay the resolution of a pressure point
Characters are just like real people – they don’t know what the outcome of a situation will be until it arrives. The pressure is on … until it isn’t. In real life, those moments just before resolution can feel like time is stretching out. You might have experienced this if your car’s ever slid into a skid, or you’ve fallen from a height, or you’ve been in a situation in which you felt threatened or frightened.
Slowing down the pace of a scene’s prose before the outcome arrives can mirror this experience. Let’s return to Tom, our field agent. Having evaded his pursuers, he’s now racing once more through the jungle and is nearing the rendezvous point. The pace is fast and provides just enough detail for readers to understand which direction he’s moving in, how fast he’s running, and that the canopy is thinning. But then he emerges at the edge of the jungle and spies the rendezvous vehicle just 30 metres away. He’s nearly safe, but the prose could delay the outcome just a little longer by homing in on the vehicle, the figure inside that Tom can’t quite make out from this distance, and the combination of fatigue and relief that threatens to overwhelm him. That slow-down in pace ekes out the moment before resolution, so that when the outcome finally arrives, it feels all the more satisfying and convincing. Summing up
Fast action and fast narrative pace are not the same thing, and slowing the latter can sometimes intensify the former.
A slow-down in pace shouldn’t merely insert more words. Something needs to change – perhaps the character notices something, understands something, feels something, decides something or waits for something consequential. That ensures that even though the pace shifts from faster to slower, momentum remains intact. When you’re considering whether the pace in an action-heavy scene is working, ask yourself: Is there a particular moment that’s worthy of extra attention? If there is, that’s a good place to consider whether it deserves a little more space on the page so readers can home in on it. The pace will slow momentarily, but their attention will increase. Related resource
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Authors: Learn how to create a character-to-prose map that helps your fiction line editor preserve character voice, emotional friction and authorial intention. With thanks to political thriller writer John W. Doedridge, who shared a perfect character-to-prose map for his debut novel Echo. It was this that helped inform my work on the free template included in this article. In this article
What is a character-to-prose map?A character-to-prose map is an author-created guide that helps a line editor understand how the characters in a novel influence the language used to portray them. And as a line editor, I think it might just be the most useful thing a writer can provide me with (bar the manuscript!). The map has two functions:
The second function is what makes the map particularly useful. It doesn’t just tell the editor who the characters are. It shows them how those characters are intended to influence the writing. And that can make a significant difference to the decisions an editor makes at sentence level, because it’s not a set of instructions telling the editor exactly what to do. Rather, it’s a guide that helps people like me navigate the prose while keeping my client’s intentions in view … right from the get-go. How is it different from a character bible?Character bibles are useful reference tools for authors and editors alike. They might contain detailed information about a character’s appearance, personality, history, relationships, motivations and development. They’re particularly helpful for maintaining continuity throughout a novel or series. A character-to-prose map, however, has a narrower, more editorial purpose. Rather than recording everything the author knows about a character, it focuses on the details that influence how that character is presented. Here’s a simple example. Character bible 'Detective Mara Ellis is emotionally guarded. She distrusts authority following a betrayal early in her career. She has a dry sense of humour and finds it difficult to express vulnerability.' What it does: This tells us something about Mara. It describes characterization. Character-to-prose map 'Detective Mara Ellis is emotionally guarded. She distrusts authority following a betrayal early in her career. She has a dry sense of humour and finds it difficult to express vulnerability. Mara’s dialogue is often clipped, and she uses sarcasm to deflect uncomfortable questions. She rarely expresses vulnerability directly. Preserve her evasions, emotional restraint and occasional awkwardness. Avoid making her feelings more explicit unless the scene calls for it.' What it does: This gives the line editor a framework for assessing whether how Mara is expressed in the prose is effective. It connects characterization to editorial decision-making. Why character knowledge matters during line editingLine editing is expression-focused work. It looks at how the language in a novel is working and whether sentence-level choices support the author’s intentions. That includes things like word choice, sentence structure, rhythm, narrative distance, dialogue, viewpoint and emotional impact. And yet none of those choices exist in isolation. They’re shaped by the characters, the situations those characters find themselves in, and the experiences that influence how they respond. Imagine a character who struggles to articulate their emotions. Their dialogue might be hesitant, indirect or awkward. Their thoughts might circle around an uncomfortable truth without acknowledging it. They might answer a question with another question or use humour to avoid revealing how they feel. A line editor who’s focused only on smoothness and clarity could unintentionally weaken those effects. Perhaps:
Individually, those edits might appear to improve the prose, but do they serve the character? That’s the question a character-to-prose map helps the editor answer. Crucially, early on in a line edit, the editor’s still getting to know the characters, and so the nuances of a character’s arc might not yet be fully apparent. Having this kind of map helps the editor serve that character’s presentation even during those early stages. What information should a character-to-prose map include?Don’t worry! I’m not going to suggest you need to create another enormous planning document. In fact, I think one of the strengths of this approach is its simplicity. A table with a few carefully chosen columns could be all you need. It can include: 1. Character name, nickname and role Record the character’s full name and any alternative names used in the manuscript. Include relevant titles or forms of address if these influence relationships or power dynamics. 2. Key traits and relevant backstory Summarize the physical, emotional and psychological characteristics that affect the character’s presentation. Include only the backstory that’s relevant to how they speak, think, behave or respond to others. 3. What the prose needs to preserve This is the most important part of the map. Alert the line editor to what matters to you about the character’s voice and how they’re represented on the page. Consider their dialogue, thought patterns, verbal habits, emotional expression, viewpoint-filtered narrative and interactions with other characters. There’s no need to give your editor a list of instructions about how they should treat every sentence – you’d be doing their job for them! Instead, it’s about helping them understand the creative intentions behind what you’ve written. A partial example of a character-to-prose map Here’s an invented example featuring three characters in a crime novel. Notice in particular that the final column doesn’t simply repeat the character information. Instead, it translates that information into something the line editor can use when assessing the prose. How the map supports editorial judgement and communicationA character-to-prose map isn’t a rulebook. It doesn’t tell an editor what to change, and it certainly doesn’t mean that every unusual sentence should remain untouched. Instead, it provides context that the editor can use when they’re making editorial decisions, and when they’re explaining them in their comments and reports. In other words, you, the author, help the likes of me, the line editor, assess what you’ve written, decide whether intervention is justified, and frame my justifications to you around the deliberate characterization choices you've told me about. It’s a delicious example of informed editorial collaboration that ensures line-level changes won’t undermine the character. When and how should you share the map with your editor?If you’re working with a line editor, I recommend sharing your character-to-prose map before the edit begins. It doesn’t need to be beautifully designed or exhaustively detailed. A simple table in Word or Excel will do the job. Two key recommendations are:
What the editor might do with it Character bibles and editorial style sheets are familiar tools in fiction writing and editing. But what a character-to-prose map does is build on those approaches by connecting an author’s knowledge of their characters with the sentence-level decisions their editor will make. For that reason, I like to incorporate a character-to-prose map into my style sheet. That way, I’m able to record editorial decisions and consistency information and capture my author’s intentions about how characterization should influence the prose. Download a free character-to-prose map templateIf you’d like to try this approach, I’ve created a simple template that you can adapt for your own novel. It includes space to record character names, relevant traits and backstory, and the aspects of character voice and emotional expression that you want your line editor to understand. You don’t need to fill in every possible detail. Start with the characters and stylistic choices that matter most. A note for editors: The map should guide, not restrictCharacters aren’t static collections of personality traits. They change, contradict themselves, make unexpected choices and respond differently depending on the circumstances. Those departures could be essential to the story, and might provide the novel with one of its most revealing moments because the changes can tell readers far more than the character’s usual behaviour does. For that reason, I think it’s really important to treat the character-to-prose map as a guide rather than a set of rules. If an editor sees something that appears to contradict the map, they shouldn’t automatically assume the writing needs amending. Rather, we need to ask whether the departure is intentional and effective. Summing upGood line editing isn’t just about making sentences clearer, tighter or smoother. It’s about understanding what the author’s trying to achieve and then helping the language deliver the intended effect. A character-to-prose map makes that partnership more effective. The author shares their knowledge of the characters and the creative intentions behind the writing. Then the editor brings their understanding of how language works and how readers might respond to it. Ultimately, the map helps both parties understand what they’re trying to achieve together. Learn professional line editing techniques
About Louise HarnbyLouise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn about six ways to make your readers ask questions so they want to keep turning the page.
In this post …
Why creating curiosity is important
Making readers ask questions is a surefire way to keep them turning the page. Why wouldn’t they? They want the answers!
Crime, thriller and mystery writers have several tools at their disposal to create that curiosity. In this post, I look at six. Bear in mind that these tools can overlap, and a single scene might use several at once. Tool 1: The opening pages
When opening pages provide a mystery in the form of, for example, a potential threat, dilemma or conspiracy, but deliberately withhold the deeper context, readers are forced to ask questions.
There’s a superb example in Lee Child’s Tripwire (Bantam Books, 1999). The prologue introduces a character named Hook Hobie. On the very first page of the story, readers are told that Hobie knows a secret that he’s been protecting for thirty years, and that he’s set up systems to detect a breach of that secret. In the two pages that follow, we learn his plan for escape in the event of the warning systems being triggered, and then, critically, that when the trigger event occurs, he reverses the escape plan he’s had in place for thirty years. What readers don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers Check that the opening pages don’t provide all the answers, but instead describe a situation that makes readers want to go looking for those answers. Tool 2: Clues
A clue might be an object, mark, missing item, unusual behaviour or speech ... in fact, any detail whose relevance and meaning only become certain later.
Depending on where they appear in a story, they may need to be subtle while still remaining visible. However, sometimes a clue will need to draw attention, even though its full meaning and relevance aren’t yet understood. In this case, readers need just enough information to register the detail and ask questions about it. In Blake Crouch’s Dark Matter (Pan, 2016), there’s an example of a barely noticeable clue in Chapter 1, when protagonist Jason Dessen looks up at a tesseract chandelier above the dining table – an anniversary present from his wife. Then in Chapter 3, following an attack, he’s given medical treatment, and returns home to find that the house is off kilter. In particular, the tesseract chandelier has morphed into one formed with antlers. It’s one of a series of clues that makes readers, and Dessen himself, ask a ton of questions. Readers know that the house belongs to Jason Dessen, and that he doesn’t recognize that space as his. What readers don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers Check the early planting of clues to ensure they don’t overexplain. If their meaning is too obvious, there’s nothing for readers to ask and less compulsion to keep reading.
Want to explore this further?
If you’re working on scenes with clues, suspicion, misdirection or unexplained behaviour in crime, mystery or thriller fiction, Line Editing for Crime, Mystery and Thriller Writers explores these topics even further. Tool 3: Unexplained behaviour
When an author shows a character making deliberately peculiar choices, readers are forced to seek a motive for them.
Chapter 1 of My Lovely Wife by Samantha Downing (Penguin, 2019) is filtered through a first-person narrator who approaches a woman in a bar and identifies himself as Tobias. He claims he’s deaf and communicates with her by phone. Later, she takes him back to her place and they go to bed. He steals her earrings – as a reminder to himself that he shouldn’t repeat this behaviour – and is about to leave when she wakes up and asks him if he’s deaf. His narration acknowledges that he must have slipped up, so readers know he’s up to something. What they don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers If a character behaves unexpectedly, give readers enough context to recognize that something is unusual, but delay the explanation. When the reason is finally revealed, make sure that the behaviour makes sense in hindsight. Tool 4: Chapter exits
When a chapter ends on a note of uncertainty, readers need to turn the page to resolve it. That uncertainty doesn’t have to be dramatic. It could be a gentle note of suspense that simply makes the reader wonder how a character will react.
There’s a lovely example of this in Rory Clements’s historical thriller Holy Spy (Hodder, 2015, pp. 130–131). At the end of the chapter, undercover intelligence officer John Shakespeare prepares to leave the house of a character he’s been interviewing. In the final two lines he opens the door and comes face to face with someone unexpected outside. The chapter ends. Readers know who the unexpected character is, and that Shakespeare doesn’t trust him. What they don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers If a chapter ending feels flat and uninspiring, look for the next interesting development in that scene (it might be on the next page or further along) and consider whether it can be relocated so that readers’ curiosity is piqued. Tool 5: Withheld context
As the Lee Child example above showed, withholding the context of the details in a scene can be extremely effective when it comes to driving reader curiosity.
Withholding does need to be carefully controlled. If information is withheld but the story can’t account for that delay in a way that makes sense, readers might feel as if the author isn’t playing fair – that the withholding hasn’t been properly earned. The withholding in the Child example makes sense because the psychic distance in the chapter is close enough to filter the narrative through what Hobie is focusing on in the moment. Andy Weir’s Project Hail Mary (Penguin Random House, 2021) also uses the withholding tool to create reader questions. There are multiple scenes throughout the novel that gradually reveal how protagonist Ryland Grace has ended up where he is, but it’s only when readers are eighty per cent through the book that they have the full context. The withholding is accounted for by Grace’s traumatic memory loss and gradual recovery, so the questions readers have in those scenes are also Grace’s questions. Until then, both we and he know that he’s in space and on a mission, but what we don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers When revealing context gradually to readers, make sure that the story accounts for the delay. Tool 6: Contradictions
Readers become curious when two pieces of information don’t fit together comfortably. Unlike with withheld context, they have enough information to understand that there’s a mismatch but not enough to explain it.
The contradiction might involve two different accounts of an event, someone’s account of an action conflicting with what they actually did, or two pieces of evidence that appear at odds with each other. There’s a smashing example of this in Mick Herron’s Spook Street (John Murray, 2017). On p. 107, Claude Whelan, First Desk at MI5, presents evidence to the prime minister that identifies a bomber and their movements prior to an explosion at a shopping centre. The bomber’s identity appears to be firmly documented. However, later, that history turns out to have been fabricated by MI5, no less, and the legend was supposed to be inactive. What readers don’t know, but want to, is:
Tip for writers Make sure the contradiction is visible enough to register, but delay explaining the mismatch. What the questions should never be
The first question no reader should ever be asking is: Why on earth am I reading this information now? Watch out for:
The second question no reader should be asking once they’ve finished the book is: Why didn’t that make sense? That kind of problem would be the result of logic slipups that cause confusion. Watch out for characters who:
Summing up
Creating curiosity is about giving readers enough information to make them ask questions, while delaying the answers just long enough to keep them engaged.
Opening pages, clues, unexplained behaviour, chapter exits, withheld context and contradictions can all do that work in different ways. The key is to make sure that the questions arise from the story rather than from confusion. Readers should be wondering what happens next, what something means or how apparently conflicting information fits together – not why they’re being shown something or why the story no longer makes sense. Further reading
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn what pace, urgency, momentum and tension are and why they’re distinct elements of crime, mystery and thriller scenes, even though they often work together.
In this post
What is scene pace?
Pace is the speed at which readers move through the scene’s narrative. It can be fast, slow or somewhere in between.
A fast-paced scene doesn’t necessarily mean it’s full of action or full of movement at speed. For example:
Nor does a slow-paced scene have to involve events that take place over a long passage of time. For example:
Tip for writers and editors
What matters is that the amount of description appropriately slows or speeds up how quickly readers move through the details. What is urgency?
Urgency is often confused with fast pacing, but I like to think of it in more specific terms – not in terms of speed, but in terms of a narrowing window of opportunity and the cost or stakes if a character fails to act in time.
That doesn’t mean urgency won’t require speed on the character’s part. It might very well, but it’s not automatic. Speedy action could therefore be a consequence of an urgent deadline, but it might not be. It depends when the deadline is. For example:
Tip for writers and editors
What matters is that readers understand what the cost will be if the character doesn’t achieve their goal in time.
Want to explore further?
If you’re working on a scene's pace, urgency, momentum or tension in crime, mystery or thriller fiction, Line Editing for Crime, Mystery and Thriller Writers explores these topics in even more detail. What is momentum?
Momentum is another element that sometimes gets mixed up with speed. In fact, momentum is about forward direction, not how fast an action is being carried out.
Key to momentum is cause and effect – something happens that causes another thing to happen. We experience momentum in our daily lives even in the most mundane of tasks. For example:
And so, an initial pressure point – me being thirsty and cold – leads to a seven-hour wait in A&E. That’s momentum in action. (And a reason to get an electric kettle that switches itself off.)
The example above has lots of drama going on, just as there might be in a chase or escape scene, or during a fraught evacuation or interrogation. But momentum is key in even the quietest of scenes because it ensures that the scene’s changing and developing rather than remaining static. Here’s a summary of a far gentler scene on pp. 72–3 of Tim Weaver’s No One Home (Penguin, 2019).
It’s a gentle, slow-paced scene that moves from Raker’s initial waking and disorientation, through to professional curiosity, then alarm, then personal revelation. Each development in the scene has a causal effect on the next, so readers are always moving forward and learning something new, even if it’s a small detail or a changed emotion.
Tip for writers and editors
What matters is that the scene progresses logically, regardless of how fast that progression occurs or whether or not there’s a deadline with a cost attached to not meeting it. What is tension?
Tension is apprehension or uncertainty about what might happen. Again, that tension might exist in a passage with a slow, deliberate pace that’s designed to draw readers’ attention to details, or a fast pace where a situation quickly escalates.
In the slow-paced Raker scene outlined above, there’s tension – first on account of Raker’s disorientation, then the unease he feels when he hears a noise he can’t explain. That tension resolves in the heartbreaking understanding that his friend is in emotional distress. However, later in the book, we learn that Raker has been imprisoned underground for several weeks. The pace is fast – we learn how he’s used this time in the darkness to put the evidence together. Though his situation is grim, the tension is low because it’s evidential piecing-together. But then a sliver of light appears, along with a rope. The pace slows as Raker, now out of reflective mode, focuses on his present dilemma – the rope might be a trap. He decides to climb anyway, and readers experience his terror and disorientation as he discovers he’s in the middle of nowhere and someone is trying to shoot him. A game of cat-and-mouse ensues, followed by a fight scene. Throughout this extended sequence that covers several chapters, the tension is thick enough to cut, as a terrified Raker tries to thwart his attacker and stay alive.
Tip for writers and editors
What matters is that any certainty about the outcome is delayed. That keeps readers rooting for the protagonist and turning the page to find out what happens. Why understanding the differences matters
Understanding the differences helps writers diagnose why a scene feels rushed, static, flat or slow in the wrong places.
Details might need to be summarized quickly (fast pace) because they’re important for reader orientation, but that’s all. Equally, they might matter and the pace might need to slow, because without them, the issue is resolved too quickly and there’s no tension. Details that don’t affect what happens next – that seem to arrive in a void – can leave readers feeling stranded, unsure why they’re accessing an important moment of reflection or backstory at this point in the scene. Whether the information is whizzed through or described with precision, there still needs to be cause and effect so that the reader moves forward logically (momentum). Narrowing windows of opportunity (urgency) will determine the actions a character takes and when they take them, and while momentum needs to be intact, the pace and tension may ebb and flow. And uncertainty might last for only a short moment in a passage (as is the case in the first Raker example), or stretch out over separate chapters (as in the second Raker example). Summing up
Pace, urgency, momentum and tension can all work together, but they do different things.
Pace controls how quickly readers move through a scene, urgency narrows the characters’ window of opportunity, momentum keeps the scene moving forward through cause and effect, and tension creates uncertainty about what will happen. Use them together, but don’t treat them as interchangeable. Related resource
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Fiction line editing isn’t a mysterious instinct. Discover how analytical editors can learn the skills and frameworks they need to edit fiction.
In this post …
A special kind of brain?
Some editors assume they’re simply not wired for fiction. They’re too analytical, too academic or too comfortable with the logic of non-fiction.
But I don’t believe there’s a special kind of brain required to line edit a novel. Fiction line editing isn’t a mysterious instinct. It’s a skill, and skills can be learned. In fact, many of the analytical abilities experienced non-fiction editors already use provide an excellent foundation. You don’t want to line edit fiction
Some editors don’t want to line edit fiction, and that’s fine.
You might love the precision of academic editing, the structure of business content or the satisfaction of making complicated non-fiction clearer. You might look at a 90,000-word novel and feel absolutely no desire to get involved whatsoever. Fair enough. Nobody needs to edit everything. However, there’s another group of editors I’m much more interested in … You do want to line edit fiction, but think you can’t
Some editors would love to line edit fiction. They love reading novels and are curious about how their colleagues go about working on it. Perhaps they’ve even considered taking on fiction work, but pulled back because they think they can’t.
The doubts I hear most often from editors I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve heard colleagues say things like, ‘I’d love to work on fiction but …’
Give them an awkward sentence, a structural inconsistency or a poorly organized chapter in a non-fiction book and they’re perfectly happy. But give them a novel and suddenly everything feels different ... subjective, instinctive. Even a bit mysterious. And I don’t buy it. I think they’ve been fed a myth. There isn’t a special fiction-editing brain
I honestly don’t believe that fiction editors are born with a mysterious ability to look at a passage of prose and simply know what’s wrong with it or what’s right with it, why it’s working or not working, why it’s engaging or flat.
I’d even go as far as saying that I think that approach is a little arrogant. That’s not to say that experienced fiction editors never work intuitively. We do. We might sense that a scene is dragging, that a character’s reaction doesn’t quite ring true, that the viewpoint has become unstable or that a piece of dialogue isn’t doing what the writer needs it to do. But that instinct didn’t appear from nowhere. It was built. It comes from knowledge, close reading, experience, pattern recognition and practice. The very same thing happens in other kinds of editing:
And yet we wouldn’t usually describe those abilities as mysterious, not at all. Instead, we’d recognize them as expertise. And just like non-fiction editors, the skills fiction editors have learned eventually become a kind of muscle memory. So why do we sometimes treat fiction differently? How fiction editing is talked about
There’s no shortage of advice about editing fiction: Show, don’t tell. Avoid head-hopping. Make your characters believable. Give every scene a purpose. Raise the stakes. Keep the reader turning the pages. Watch the pacing. Make the dialogue sound natural.
All of these ideas are important. However, there’s a huge difference between knowing a principle and knowing how to analyse a manuscript to check whether those principles are in play. Suppose you’re reading a scene and something feels flat. What do you do next?
For someone who thinks analytically, a collection of fiction-writing and editing principles can feel frustratingly loose. You know the terminology and you understand the advice in theory, but when an actual manuscript lands in front of you, you still don’t know where to start. I think that’s where many editors conclude that they simply don’t have the right instincts for fiction. And yet I’m not convinced that it’s because of how they’re wired. I think instead that what they’re actually missing is structure. Analytical editors are better equipped than they think
If you come from an academic, technical, business or other non-fiction editing background, you already know how to analyse and ask questions such as:
Those habits are critical for novel editing, and while the questions and the language used to explain the solutions might change because a work of fiction is trying to do different things, the shift is sometimes actually quite subtle. Plus, the underlying analytical process is still in play. And so the fiction editor might ask:
Those are analytical questions. And once you start asking them, fiction becomes much less mysterious. Analysis isn’t the same thing as imposing a formula
This is where I think people sometimes become wary. When those of us who love an analytical approach to fiction editing start talking about ‘frameworks’, ‘systems’ and ‘analysis’, it can sound as though we’re trying to turn fiction into mathematics.
Put Character A here. Add some conflict on page 12. Insert an emotional response. Increase tension by 17 per cent. Novel edit complete. If only! But that isn’t what I mean. Good fiction is far too varied for that. For example, a literary novel and a fast-paced thriller are not trying to create the same reading experience. A comic novel can succeed by doing something that would be disastrous in a psychological thriller. And a technique that works beautifully for one writer could feel completely wrong in the hands of another. And so a framework isn’t there to tell us what a book must do. Instead, it helps us work out what this particular book is trying to do – and whether the choices on the page are helping it succeed. That distinction really matters. Analysis isn’t about forcing a manuscript to conform to a template, but rather about understanding cause and effect.
Once you can see those relationships, you can make editorial decisions for reasons you can explain. That’s much more useful than ‘It just feels wrong’. In fact, it’s essential because fiction editors need to be able to explain and justify their recommendations to an author, not just suggest changes that appear random and based on gut feeling. Structure gives you somewhere to start
This is the part I care about most when I teach fiction editing (and when I report to my clients).
I want editors to have a way into the manuscript. I’m not talking about a giant checklist they have to apply mechanically or a set of commandments, but rather a route – a way of getting under the skin of a novel at scene level. If something feels like it’s not working, I want them to be able to slow down, break the problem apart and ask useful questions:
From there, you can start identifying why a passage works or doesn’t work. And once you know why, your editorial suggestions become much more precise and genuinely useful for your author. Instead of saying ‘This scene is a bit slow’, you can explain what’s making it feel slow and offer options that would solve the problem. Or rather than saying, ‘I’m not connecting with this character’, you can examine what information the reader’s been given, the degree of psychic distance, what the character wants and how their emotional responses are being presented. Or rather than ‘This dialogue doesn’t sound natural,’ you can look at what the speech is actually doing: whether both characters sound the same, whether they’re saying things they already know for the reader’s benefit, whether the exchange has an underlying purpose, whether the characters are responding to one another or simply taking turns delivering information. The judgement is still yours, but now you have something to base it on. Instinct comes later
There’s nothing wrong with editorial instinct; it’s incredibly useful. But I think we sometimes get the order backwards.
We tell people to trust their instincts before they’ve had the opportunity to develop them. An experienced editor might read three lines and immediately sense a point-of-view problem, whereas a newer fiction editor might need to stop and work through it deliberately, asking questions such as:
That slower process isn’t evidence that they’re bad at fiction editing, but rather that they’re practising their art and honing their skills. And when you do something consciously often enough, eventually you start doing parts of it automatically. In other words, the framework doesn’t replace instinct but instead helps you build it. The language is different, but the skills are familiar
The terminology can make fiction line editing feel more alien than it really is. Words and phrases like psychic distance, viewpoint, backstory, scene momentum and character voice might feel unfamiliar, but many of the underlying editorial skills aren’t.
The terminology and material change, but the analytical habits are often much more familiar than they first appear.
Wrapping up: You might not have the ‘wrong kind of brain’
If you don’t want to edit fiction, don’t. There are plenty of other kinds of editing, and nobody gets bonus points for taking on work they don’t enjoy.
But if you do want to line edit fiction and the thing stopping you is the belief that you’re too analytical, too academic or simply not wired for it, I’d ask you to challenge that assumption. Your analytical brain may not be the obstacle. In fact, it might be one of your biggest assets. Why? Because you already know how to examine language closely; identify patterns, inconsistencies and gaps; and ask what a piece of writing is trying to achieve and whether it succeeds. Working on fiction doesn’t mean throwing those skills away, but instead learning how to apply them to a different kind of text. Fiction editing isn’t some mysterious instinct, I promise you. It’s a skill. And skills can be learned. Related resourcesAbout Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn about how pressure works in crime, mystery and thriller fiction, and how it shapes character behaviour, emotion and momentum.
In this post …
What are scene pressure points?
Pressure points are the problems, questions, threats, needs or emotional strain that shape a scene. They shape how a character behaves – emotionally and physically – while they’re managing pressure.
They might arise from something a character is hiding, pursuing, trying to understand or frightened of. Why is pressure important?
Pressure is the backbone of a scene’s momentum. It’s the reason why this scene, right now, at this point in the book is relevant and needs to progress. Think of it as a jumping-off point.
Pressure points in novels are not unlike pressure points in real life. Think about the various things you do throughout the day, and what the driving force behind each of those is. For example, you might:
The text in bold reflects life’s pressure points. The text in italic is how that pressure shapes actions and emotions. It’s a good reminder that even everyday actions have some sort of impetus behind them that drives what we do, and it’s that impetus that needs to be captured in a novel’s scene.
Want to explore this topic further?
Pressure is a recurring theme throughout my book Line Editing for Crime, Mystery and Thriller Writers. Is scene pressure always dramatic?
Pressure absolutely doesn’t have to involve high-octane, all-guns-blazing action; it might just as well be quiet and reflective.
Take a look at the five scene summaries below, and notice how the temperature of the pressure shifts according to what Espin, our investigator and viewpoint character, is dealing with.
Keeping pressure active
An immersive scene doesn’t require pressure to be completely resolved. Uncertainty’s often critical in crime, mystery and thriller fiction because it keeps readers turning the pages as they seek understanding and try to fit the pieces of the puzzle together.
Equally, if the pressure doesn’t change, the scene could end up dragging because readers aren’t discovering anything new. The solution is to review scenes to ensure that the pressure shifts. Here’s an example in which Espin is interviewing the witness, whom we’ll call Arne Nilsen. I’ve numbered each line so we can track how different pressure points emerge and manifest.
Example
Pressure analysis
The pressure in that scene isn’t completely resolved. However, the pressure points change depending on what the characters need, discover and experience. Summing up
Pressure can be inferred from a character’s dialogue, thoughts, subtext and observable behaviours. It can be dramatic, reflective or somewhere in between.
What’s important is that the reader understands where it comes from and how it changes so that the scene moves forward. Related resource
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how restricted viewpoint works in crime fiction and thrillers, and how to manage perspective, control character knowledge and build suspense effectively.
In this post …
Why viewpoint is important in crime and thriller writing
In crime fiction and thrillers, effective storytelling comes from what happens, and from what the reader is allowed to know and when they’re allowed to know it.
A crime or transgression is only the beginning. The real tension lies in who saw what, or who misunderstood it, and what the narrative reveals or conceals at any given moment. That control is handled through viewpoint. Handled well, viewpoint should be invisible to the reader. Handled poorly, it dilutes suspense, gives away twists too early and can leave readers feeling shut out rather than engaged. Which narrative viewpoint choice works best?
There’s more than one option when it comes to narrative viewpoint.
Omniscient viewpoint – where the narrative can access any characters’ thoughts and feelings, moves freely between them, and provides information beyond what any one character could know – is a legitimate option. However, it’s an extremely rare choice in contemporary crime fiction and thriller writing, mainly because if you don’t nail it perfectly, it feels like head-hopping. Head-hopping is an uncontrolled shift between characters’ thoughts or perspectives within a scene without clear transitions. This can create confusion for readers, and it can also prevent them from immersing themselves deeply in the experiences of any one character. Most mainstream authors tend to go for a restricted (or limited) narrative viewpoint, blended with some objectivity. It’s a great choice because, as long as you stick to the rules of what the reader is allowed to know and when, it’s much easier to control. One of my favourite ways of explaining those rules is through the principle of earned knowledge. What ‘earned knowledge’ actually means
Earned knowledge is the idea that readers know only what the viewpoint/perspective character could reasonably know at that moment, and only in the way that the character experiences it.
For example, if a law-enforcement officer is the viewpoint character, they won’t know that someone they’re watching or questioning is nervous. However, what they could notice is information such as a flicker in the suspect’s hand, a hesitation in their speech or a too-long glance at the nearest exit. Or the suspect could say that they’re nervous. From that observable and audible information, they might conclude that their suspect is nervous, but it’s a subjective interpretation, not an objective fact that can be handed to the reader. Even if the suspect said out loud that they’re nervous, the officer can’t know for sure that what’s spoken is actually reliable. And so neither can the reader. For the reader to properly know what the suspect is really feeling, the suspect must be the viewpoint character. Then, and only then, can the reader access to their thoughts and emotions. In other words, the reader’s earned the right to that interior emotionality. Let’s explore how restricted and objective viewpoints might work in your crime and thriller writing, and they’ll help you control what your reader can know and when they’re allowed to know it. Restricted viewpoint – single viewpoint character in a novel
Alternative terms: Limited viewpoint, limited POV (point of view), single-character POV, fixed viewpoint, constrained POV, bounded perspective, subjective viewpoint, locked POV, tethered narration, inside-one-head narration.
In this tightly restricted single-character viewpoint, the reader is confined entirely to one character’s awareness throughout the whole novel. Example In Chapter 1, the narrative describes how our detective viewpoint character – let’s call him Taylor – enters a quiet house. Readers know only:
Further chapters go on to narrate what Taylor learns as his investigation progresses and he pieces together the clues. This is classic close third-person or first-person technique, and the effect is simple but powerful: the reader is trapped in shared ignorance with a single character. Every discovery lands as a genuine revelation. Earned knowledge writing tip: Make sure that what the reader knows has been earned by accessing only what your single viewpoint character can know through internal and external experience. Restricted viewpoint – multiple viewpoint characters in a novel
Alternative terms: Multiple limited POV, multiple viewpoint characters (limited POV), multi-POV (limited), alternating limited POV, rotating limited POV, shifting limited viewpoint, multiple restricted viewpoints, sequential viewpoint narration, distributed viewpoint narration.
Some writers allow the reader to explore the awareness of multiple viewpoint characters. It’s common in crime and thriller writing to separate these perspectives by chapter or section. That way, the reader isn’t hopping in and out of different heads without knowing where the transition points are. Having multiple viewpoint characters doesn’t remove restriction. Each chapter/scene is still limited to one perspective, but the reader’s overall knowledge expands with every shift. In this case, the writer has to do two things at once:
Shared ignorance gradually collapses as the reader gradually comes to know more than any one character does on their own. This can really help build tension, anticipation and even dread. Example In Chapter 1, a person enters their home. Readers know only:
In Chapter 2, a detective – Taylor – enters the quiet house. Now he’s the viewpoint character, and so readers know only:
In Chapter 3, we see things from yet another person’s perspective. Now they’re the viewpoint character, and readers know only:
Here, each chapter still has a restricted viewpoint. However:
Earned knowledge writing tip: Make sure that what the reader knows has been earned by accessing only what each separate viewpoint character can know through internal and external experience, and then control what order they come by this information. This keeps them guessing. Objective viewpoint
Alternative terms: Fly-on-the-wall narration, camera-eye POV, external viewpoint, surface-level POV, external-camera perspective, no access narration, dramatic point of view.
With an objective viewpoint, the writer focuses on providing external and audible information. Readers have no access to thoughts or internal states. The reader earns their access to this information because it’s what they could report if they were watching CCTV footage or were a fly on the wall. In the examples above, we saw how a narrative can blend objective and subjective experience. However, writers sometimes choose to pan out and write a scene that’s wholly objective. Here’s what the narrative might focus on in a purely objective scene:
Example A man in a dark jacket enters the interview room at 10.14 and sits down at the table. He places a folded newspaper beside his right hand, glances at his watch, then taps the table twice with a finger. The door opens. A woman steps in and sits across from him. She places a file on the table but doesn’t open it. ‘Mr Carter?’ she says. He nods once. The woman opens the file, removes a photograph and slides it across the table. Carter looks at the photograph, but his hand remains on the newspaper. ‘That’s not mine.’ The woman watches him for several seconds, then says, ‘You were seen entering the building at 21.42.’ Carter leans back in his chair. Shrugs. ‘So what? I go in there all the time.’ The narrative in this scene reports behaviour that would be accessible to anyone watching and listening. Readers aren’t told what’s going on in either character’s mind. Instead, they have to infer it all from clues in the movement and dialogue. The man’s tapping finger, single nod and shrug could imply a dismissive arrogance. The controlled pauses on the part of the woman could imply a patient confidence. But for now, readers can only guess. They haven’t earned actual knowledge. Earned knowledge writing tip: Make sure that what the reader knows has been earned through externally observable and audible information. Tackling time: When to withhold or reveal
Withholding information is essential in crime fiction and thrillers because that’s what builds suspense and keeps the reader guessing about what’s going on.
However, that delay needs to be earned so that important information doesn’t come out of the blue but was seeded. Example A witness mentions ‘someone in a red coat’ early in the story. The phrase seems incidental at that point but, later, a red coat reappears in on CCTV footage. This gives the investigator a robust line of inquiry to follow, and it makes sense to the reader because they’d already mentally archived the detail. Delays like this are effective because the writer didn’t hide the information. It was there in plain sight all along, but the reader didn’t have enough information to understand its relevance earlier on. Contrast that with artificial withholding, where the narrative deliberately avoids mentioning something the viewpoint character clearly experiences. When that happens, and something emerges later that feels too conveniently shoehorned in, readers will feel manipulated or cheated. Earned knowledge writing tip: If the character would notice it in the moment, the reader should be allowed to see it too. Advanced control: Manipulating reader knowledge
Sometimes writers withhold important information because they want to keep a reader guessing, and they worry that they might give the game away too early.
A useful technique you can use in this case is engineered ambiguity. Here, the reader receives accurate information, but just enough so that it can be interpreted in multiple ways. Example In an early scene, a witness sees a man help an injured child, then hurry out of the building with blood on his sleeve. However, the writer wants the reader to think that the bloody sleeve could be as a result of something more sinister. The key is not to delay mentioning the man hurrying from the building or his bloody sleeve, but instead to relocate the witness so that they don’t know that the man helped an injured child. That way, the relevant context can be uncovered later. And, importantly, nothing revealed in the earlier scene was false. It was simply incomplete. Earned knowledge writing tip: Don’t lie to readers. Instead, give them knowledge that can be interpreted in different ways. Recap of how the reader’s knowledge is controlled with different viewpoint structures
The infographic below summarises how different viewpoint choices shape what the reader knows in crime fiction and thrillers.
Each approach controls information in a different way – by limiting it to one character, distributing it across multiple perspectives, restricting it to external observation, or expanding it through omniscient access. Across all of them, the key principle remains the same: the reader’s knowledge is carefully earned through the way the narrative is structured. Summing up
Most contemporary crime and thriller writers rely on a restricted or limited viewpoint to carefully control earned knowledge – what the reader is allowed to know, and when they are allowed to know it.
Rather than using a single fixed mode, you can blend restricted POV for deep, character experience with moments of objective narration for external clarity and distance. Across both approaches, the principle stays the same: information is never simply given to the reader. It’s earned as they assemble what’s revealed to them … and what’s withheld. By carefully managing that, you’ll ensure that your story stays one step ahead of its audience, and that you give your readers plenty of what thy love about this genre – tension and suspense. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn about ‘shared ignorance’ in crime fiction and thrillers, and how writers use missing information to build suspense, mislead readers and deliver powerful twists.
In this post …
What is shared ignorance?
Being in a state of shared ignorance means that a character and a reader both lack the same information at the same time. You’ll see it in play where a story focuses on a single viewpoint character throughout the novel – when we’re in just one character’s head.
I like the term ‘shared ignorance’ because it captures the deep emotional connection between the reader and the viewpoint character. Whatever they don’t know, we don’t know. Whatever they miss, we miss. Whatever path they go down, we go down. Shared ignorance and psychic distance
Because the character and reader experiences are aligned, the psychic distance between them is very narrow. The reader is effectively inside the character’s perspective.
Instead of observing the mystery from a distance, the reader becomes an active participant in solving it. Together, reader and viewpoint character share the process of investigation, misdirection, discovery and revelation, plus all the emotional stuff that comes with it – bafflement, anticipation, tension and relief. How shared ignorance works
At its core, shared ignorance is about controlling information – who has it, who doesn’t and when it’s revealed.
Critically, we as readers, are never one step ahead as a result of having learned something elsewhere in the story that our main character doesn’t know. We take the journey with them. Let’s imagine that our viewpoint character is an investigator called Harris.
These kinds of limitations ensure that the reader discovers the truth alongside the investigator, rather than ahead of them. What the restrictions are
If a story is tightly bound to the perspective of a single character who knows no more than the reader, then anything outside of that character’s awareness or interpretive ability is effectively off-limits. For example:
These constraints mean that the reader solves the mystery alongside the investigator. The discipline required to preserve integrity
Taking a tight character-bound approach obviously needs discipline to ensure that the integrity of the plot doesn’t collapse.
In addition to considering the restraints above, never forget that the narrative mustn’t reveal more than the viewpoint character can reasonably perceive or infer, and equally mustn’t withhold what they already know. So, if the character misses obvious clues, draws conclusions that clearly aren’t supported, or remembers things that weren’t previously reported, the illusion of a shared journey will break down, and the reader’s trust will go with it. At its core, this is a question of fairness. The reader should always feel that, given the same information, they could have reached the truth alongside the investigator. 5 practical principles for you to follow
Here are five practical principles to help you manage shared ignorance during the writing or editing process:
Why shared ignorance is effective
Shared ignorance is effective because it taps into how people behave. When we’re presented with incomplete information:
Crime fiction and thrillers exploit these tendencies, and stories that operate through a lens of shared ignorance provide a reading experience that feels active rather than passive. We’re following a story, and we’re trying to solve its conundrums. Summing up
The most compelling stories create a world in which characters and readers don’t see the answers until exactly the right moment.
If you’re writing from the perspective of a single character, shared ignorance will keep your readers turning the pages, second-guessing themselves and chasing down the solution. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to use foreshadowing in crime fiction and thrillers to build suspense, plant clues and keep readers guessing without giving too much away.
In this post
What foreshadowing is
Foreshadowing is the controlled planting of information that only becomes fully meaningful later in a story. Think of it as a warning or sign – one that might be subtle or more explicit.
Rather than announcing what will happen, writers place carefully chosen details into the narrative so that, in hindsight, the outcome feels both surprising but logical. In crime fiction and thrillers, that’s especially important because the reader is actively encouraged to try to unravel the mystery rather than just follow it. Foreshadowing can be part of that problem-solving process. Is foreshadowing always about unease?
People sometimes assume that foreshadowing is about uneasy or ominous vibes, especially in crime fiction and thrillers. That association probably comes from how frequently the technique is used in those genres, rather than from what foreshadowing actually is.
In fact, foreshadowing is a neutral mechanism – one through which emotion is born. In other words, the emotion is the consequence. Foreshadowing details can certainly create a sense of unease, but they could equally produce other emotions. Which ones will depend on your story. Possibilities could include:
What effective foreshadowing achieves
Done effectively, foreshadowing:
Foreshadowing and shared uncertainty
Foreshadowing works best when the reader and viewpoint character have the same limited knowledge and shared uncertainty. In this situation:
Foreshadowing inside a state of shared uncertainty is especially powerful because it feels like the fictional world is gradually revealing itself to both of you at once, rather than the author speaking to the reader. And that’s the key thing. When you introduce foreshadowing to your writing, you don’t want it to seem like some external narrator is tapping your reader on the shoulder and shouting hints into their ear. Instead, suggestion is embedded into the character’s experience. How foreshadowing drives suspense
Suspense is the sustained feeling of uncertainty and anticipation that arises when a reader knows something important is at stake but doesn’t yet know how, when or whether it will be resolved.
Foreshadowing can help build suspense by separating information from understanding. For example, a character (and therefore the reader) could:
Suspense emerges from the gap between what’s seen and what’s understood. Instead, the reader will ask: What does this mean? Why was this detail included? Is this important or misleading? When done well, foreshadowing keeps those questions active but doesn’t answer them too early. 4 examples of effective and poor foreshadowing
Here are four examples of when foreshadowing works … and when it doesn’t, each one with a short analysis of what’s going on.
Example 1: Viewpoint focus
This example includes details that foreshadow the possibility of data manipulation and internal misconduct.
Comparing the two
Notice how in the first version, the reader and the detective are investigating together. We’re inside her head and know only what she knows and feels, and what she can objectively observe. This preserves the close, restricted viewpoint, and builds a sense of uncertainty that can be explored in more detail as the investigation progresses. In the second version, however, we have a god’s-eye view. The narrative’s no longer bound by what Harris can perceive, infer or reasonably suspect. Instead, readers now have access to information that they haven’t earned the right to know because Harris hasn’t discovered it – ie Lane’s manipulation two weeks earlier. Viewpoint integrity has collapsed, and a plot point has been given away so that there’s no longer any anticipation. Any questions the reader had have been answered. Craft takeaway Foreshadowing works by embedding clues within the character’s experience. If you step outside that experience to explain those clues, you’re no longer foreshadowing. You’re simply giving the game away.
Example 2: Evidence assessment
This example includes details that foreshadow potential issues with the evidence’s provenance and integrity.
Comparing the two
In the first version, there’s a cluster of small signals that foreshadow problems with the evidence:
Taken together, these don’t point directly at the truth, but at the uncertainty of what might be the truth. The radio callout is handled credibly so that it intensifies urgency without blocking access to the information. Crucially, the evidence is captured but not yet understood. That keeps the reader in suspense, asking not what the footage shows, but whether it can be trusted, who placed it there, and how it might need to be reinterpreted. In the second version, two of those same signals are still present but they’re not acted on. The shared source and uncertain provenance both suggest that the footage may be unreliable, yet the investigator treats it as effectively definitive. The doubt is raised, then immediately flattened. This is where the foreshadowing breaks down. The story introduces uncertainty but fails to follow through on its implications, so the detail stops functioning as foreshadowing and becomes clutter. Craft takeaway Foreshadowing isn’t just about planting clues but also about honouring what those clues imply. If you introduce doubt, follow through on it. Otherwise, it isn’t foreshadowing; it’s just noise.
Example 3: Emotional history
This example includes details that foreshadow unresolved trauma or past wrongdoing.
Comparing the two
In the first version, there are foreshadowing details that create uncertainty around what Emily means when she references her past. These are:
That combination creates tension because nothing is explained, but the signs are that there’s more to the conversation than meets the eye. The second version just spits it out. There’s nothing left to infer, suspect or anticipate. By answering questions too early, rather than encouraging the reader to form those questions through the foreshadowing signals, the tension and suspense plummet. Craft takeaway Effective foreshadowing provides cues without confirming what they mean. The moment a cue is fully explained, it stops functioning as foreshadowing and becomes exposition.
Example 4: Ominous event
This example includes details that foreshadow the later significance and threat associated with the envelope.
Comparing the two
The foreshadowing in these versions is more explicit than in Examples 1–3, yet only one is effective. The difference comes down to trust: one shows, while the other tells. The first version trusts the reader to notice patterns – the flicker, the silence and the weight of the envelope – and draw their own conclusions. It builds unease through specific sensory details while still leaving space for uncertainty and interpretation. Contrast this with the second version, which doesn’t trust the reader at all. It repeatedly interrupts itself to explain what everything means and why it matters, draining the tension and making the voice feel performative. Craft takeaway When you’re tempted to explain why a detail matters, cut the explanation and strengthen the detail instead. A concrete image (like the unexpected weight of the envelope) will carry far more tension than a sentence telling the reader it’s important. Tips for controlling foreshadowing
Here are some practical tips to help you control your foreshadowing:
Plant early and pay off later Introduce details long before they become important, rather than in the moment of revelation. That way no one will be able to accuse you of unearned writing – whereby the outcomes, emotions or revelations aren’t justified by what’s come before, making them feel unconvincing to the reader. Look ordinary at first mention Effective foreshadowing detail looks like ordinary but interesting detail at first mention, but gains further meaning later. Vary the level of clarity Some of your foreshadowing details can be obvious in hindsight, giving your reader an of-course moment. Others might be almost invisible until they’re re-examined. By varying the level of clarity, you avoid setting up patterns that the reader might spot. Ensure retrospective meaning Effective foreshadowed detail has a purpose and always earns its place later. If you put something in but it never becomes relevant, there’s a risk that you’ve unnecessarily cluttered your prose. Track reader knowledge Make sure you track what clues the reader has actually been shown and can reasonably remember, so that they can recognize them and accept the logic in play. Avoid signalling too loudly If the reader can guess the outcome too early because your foreshadowing signals are noisy, you’ll turn an opportunity for suspense into confirmation. The key with good foreshadowing is to ensure it’s both subtle and relevant. Summing up
Foreshadowing is not about hiding information or predicting outcomes in advance, but about shaping how readers interpret information over time.
The most effective foreshadowing often feels like ordinary detail in the moment, and then becomes meaningful in hindsight. But even more explicit foreshadowing that hints at a future dramatic event needs to hold back so that there’s space for the reader’s curiosity and anticipation. Do your best not to overexplain too early. That way you’ll preserve the tension and suspense. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to use red herrings to create believable false conclusions, deepen mystery structure, and keep readers confidently wrong at just the right moments.
In this post ...
What is a red herring?
A red herring is a storytelling device that introduces information that appears to support a plausible explanation, but ultimately leads to the wrong conclusion.
Bear in mind that red herrings are not always limited to characters or their motives. Some writers construct them around how an entire fictional world works. What’s the difference between a red herring and controlled misdirection?
I like to separate red herrings from the idea of controlled misdirection because a red herring feels heavier.
While it does involve misdirection, it works by building a false but plausible explanatory path that steers the reader towards an incorrect conclusion, only to collapse later under the weight of the real solution. This not only delays the reader’s understanding, but also forces them to construct a competing narrative that appears to solve the mystery … until it doesn’t. Sometimes writers like to introduce other points of misdirection that are less weighty. These focus not on shaping the conclusion, but how information is interpreted in the moment. These are what I call ‘controlled misdirection’. >> Find out more about controlled misdirection here. Key distinction At their core, the difference is this: Controlled misdirection shapes how the reader interprets information, while red herrings construct a complete but ultimately false explanation. In practice, both can appear alongside each other in crime fiction. They’re just operating slightly differently. Writing red herrings: The golden rules
All effective red herrings should be:
What a red herring is not: Common misconceptions
Here’s what a red herring is not ...
It’s not controlled misdirection (according to my framework) Controlled misdirection uses true information that’s misinterpreted. A red herring may include this, but its defining feature is the construction of a complete but ultimately false explanation. It’s not a twist Twists are sudden, unexpected revelations that reshape a reader’s interpretation of earlier events and alter their understanding of the story. In short, they resolve uncertainty, whereas red herrings prolong it by sending the reader down the wrong path. It’s not foreshadowing Foreshadowing plants early clues or hints that later gain meaning, while a red herring builds a complete but false path that’s later exposed as untrue. It’s not factual deception A red herring does not mislead the reader about facts. Instead, it misleads them about the explanation those facts appear to support. It’s not withholding Withholding is about timing – when information is revealed. A red herring is about what explanation the reader is encouraged to believe, not when information appears. How red herrings work: The mechanics
Here’s a simple framework for constructing effective red herrings, followed by a couple of examples of the mechanism in practice.
Below are a couple of examples from two published novels. I’ve framed the analyses broadly so that they focus on the mechanisms rather than any plot details. However, if these books are on your reading list, perhaps come back to this article when you’ve devoured the novels. That way, you’ll enter those fictional worlds completely green. These examples show how the same underlying mechanism can operate at different levels: worldbuilding in one case, and character psychology in another. Example 1: The Bedlam Stacks, by Natasha Pulley Pulley’s novel is a smashing example of how a red herring can go beyond suspects and be structural, working on how the story’s world works. The setup
The reinforcement
The commitment
The collapse
Example 2: Gone Girl, by Gillian Flynn Flynn’s novel is an excellent example of layered red herrings based around people and psychology. The setup
The reinforcement
The commitment
The collapse
Summing up
A strong red herring should distract the reader’s attention, but it must do so in a way that makes them believe in what is a complete and convincing explanation of the mystery, even though it will ultimately prove false.
The key is to stick to the golden rules so that readers are confidently wrong, but for the right reasons. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to use controlled misdirection to guide your reader towards convincing but incorrect interpretations, and build deeper, more engaging mysteries.
In this post
What is controlled misdirection?
Controlled misdirection is a deliberate storytelling technique that leads the reader towards a convincing but incorrect interpretation of information.
When done well, it doesn’t feel like a trick but like something natural and logical – even though, later, that information will turn out to be incomplete or misjudged. What’s the difference between a red herring and controlled misdirection?
I like to separate controlled misdirection from red herrings because the latter feels heavier. Red herrings work by building a false but plausible explanatory path that steers the reader towards an incorrect conclusion, only to collapse later under the weight of the real solution.
However, sometimes writers like to introduce other points of misdirection that are less weighty. These focus not on shaping the conclusion, but how information is interpreted in the moment. The writer presents accurate, relevant details in a way that encourages the reader (and often the protagonist) to infer the wrong meaning from them. That’s what I call ‘controlled misdirection’. >> Find out more about red herrings here. Key distinction At their core, the difference is this: Controlled misdirection shapes how the reader interprets information, while red herrings construct a complete but ultimately false explanation. In practice, both can appear alongside each other in crime fiction. They’re just operating slightly differently. Writing controlled misdirection: The golden rules
All controlled misdirection should be:
What controlled misdirection is not: Common misconceptions
Here’s what controlled misdirection isn’t.
It’s not a lie Controlled misdirection isn’t a licence to mislead readers with false information. The reader is given accurate details, but encouraged to interpret them in a particular way. It’s not a twist Twists are sudden, unexpected revelations that reshape a reader’s interpretation of earlier events and alter their understanding of the story. In short, they resolve uncertainty, whereas controlled misdirection seeks to prolong it. It’s not a red herring (according to my framework) It’s not a red herring, at least in the classical sense, though the two often operate in close proximity in contemporary crime fiction and thrillers. Think of it like this: Controlled misdirection gives the reader true information, but shapes how they interpret it. A red herring, by contrast, introduces a coherent but ultimately false theory that steers the reader towards an incorrect conclusion. It’s not foreshadowing Controlled misdirection and foreshadowing can look similar on the surface but they’re actually working in two different directions. Controlled misdirection points away from the truth, guides the reader to an interpretation that feels right at the time, but turns out to be incomplete or incorrect, whereas foreshadowing nudges the reader towards it. It’s not withholding Withholding is about when information is revealed – it's a timing choice. Controlled misdirection, on the other hand, is active in the present and guides the reader towards an incorrect interpretation – it’s a shaping choice. How controlled misdirection works: The mechanics
Here’s a quick 4-step framework, followed by a couple of worked examples, that you can use to build effective misdirection.
Below are two examples of controlled misdirection in action. Example 1: Misdirection through forensic interpretation The setup: Readers are given accurate, relevant information
The misdirect: The information is interpreted incorrectly
The justification: The incorrect interpretation is plausible at the time
The turn: Later, this information can be reinterpreted correctly
Example 2: Misdirection through behavioural interpretation The setup: Readers are given accurate, relevant information
The misdirect: The information is interpreted incorrectly
The justification: The incorrect interpretation is plausible at the time
The turn: Later, this information can be reinterpreted correctly
Summing up
Effective controlled misdirection doesn’t make the reader feel tricked. Rather, it makes them realize that they formed an interpretation that felt logical at the time, given the information available, but turned out to be incorrect.
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
This practical framework shows you 9 steps for line editing scenes in crime and thriller fiction so that every sentence pulls its weight and delivers the appropriate level of tension.
In this post
Why your novel’s not gripping the reader
If you feel like your novel’s not gripping the reader, it’s all too easy to blame something going on at story level. Perhaps it’s not twisty enough. Maybe the plot’s too thin. Perhaps the structure’s not balanced and the prose feels saggy in the middle of the book.
Before you rework the whole thing, take a step back and ask yourself if it’s the line work. The reason I say that is because line editing for crime fiction and thrillers takes place within the same foundational framework as any other genre. However, there’s an additional matter that needs engineering at line level: tension. That tension can’t just live at the macro level – in the story. It has to have a home in the sentences too. What is line editing?
Structural editing is SHAPING work. It examines big-picture elements like plot, pacing, structure, character arcs and coherence. Editors focus on improving the clarity and impact of the whole story.
Proofreading is QUALITY CONTROL work. It focuses on surface issues, amending spelling, grammar, punctuation, formatting and consistency issues to ensure the novel’s ready for publication. Line editing is EXPRESSION work. It sits in between the structural and proofreading stages, and considers what the scene is trying to do – whether that’s creating drama, building tension, revealing character, conveying information – and then making stylistic improvements to ensure the language actually achieves that. Use the framework below to check each scene and make sure that every sentence is pulling its weight. 1. Check for clarity
The first step is to check for clarity. Here, you’re making sure that:
Just because a line is lean doesn’t mean it needs to be boring. Sometimes writers need to tell it like it is and give the reader the cleanest pathway through so that they can live in the moment of the action rather than having to untangle it. This is particularly important in high-stakes situations, where the clock is ticking or a character’s in pursuit or being pursued. Examples
In the edited version, clarity has been improved by following a cleaner telling of the order of play: time (the watch), movement (hurried) and path (direction). I’ve also used more precise verbs ('checked' and 'hurried') to show how the character’s actions are controlled. This means we can ditch the adverbs ('urgently' and 'briefly') because those verbs do the heavy-lifting. I’ve also suggested free indirect speech ('What if the … no matter'). That’s more concise and takes us into the character’s headspace without the need for the cluttering filter words ('wondered' and 'realized'). Key principle: Keep tension intact by ensuring your reader doesn’t have to stop and re-read a sentence. 2. Manage narrative velocity with sentence length
Narrative velocity is the speed at which the reader perceives events taking place in a story. At scene level, it’s shaped by sentence structure, pacing and how quickly information and action are delivered.
Just because you’re writing crime fiction or a thriller doesn’t mean the pace has to rocket in every sentence. Instead, make sure it’s controlled in a way that shows rather than tells the perceived speed. How sentence length affects perceived speed As a general rule, long sentences tend to slow the pace of a scene, while short sentences accelerate it. There’s space for both, of course, so think about what’s happening in your scene in terms of stakes. Is danger increasing? Is time running out? Is something shocking revealed? Try shortening your sentences in those cases. For extra impact, use sentence fragments – though sparingly, because then the reader won’t notice that you’re doing it, only how it makes them feel. If, however, the scene is more reflective – perhaps a law-enforcement officer is trying to make sense of some inconsistent evidence, or they’re remembering a former case – a longer sentence will mirror the more stretched-out thought process. Example
Notice how in the example above, the leading longer sentences elongate the perceived time, reflecting the tedious graft that our character’s putting in. Then, as something unexpected is discovered, shorter sentences and fragments make the prose snappier. This truncates the moment into something immediate and jarring.
This mirrors real-life human experience. When we’re under pressure we tend to think in bursts, whereas when we’re in a safe, calm space we have more time for reflection. By controlling the length of a sentence in prose we can mirror that tension, or the lack of it. Key principle: Mix up sentence length so that you’re reflecting mood. 3. Build micro-tension with rhythmic tools
Rhythm determines how quickly a reader moves through a scene. Faster rhythms can convey urgency, action, fear, anger and shock. Slower rhythms can convey sadness, calm, thoughtfulness and introspection. Interruptions to rhythm force the reader to pay attention.
We’ve already looked at how sentence length affects pacing, so here are five more rhythmic devices that you can call on at line editing stage to create or ease tension. Think about what’s happening in the scene and what the character’s feeling, then consider which tool might be most effective:
Examples In all five examples below, there are different levels of micro-tension in play, and the rhythmic tools help mirror the emotional pressure experienced by the characters.
The repetition feels weighty and emphasizes the character’s desperate longing and the pressure he’s feeling.
The omission of conjunctions in the asyndeton example allows the list to flow rapidly, conveying urgency.
Postponing who’s in the chair builds suspense.
The succession of conjunctions mirrors the character’s exhausting pursuit.
Short one-line paragraph: The man in the photo was him.
By giving this pithy one-liner its own space, the revelation lands hard.
Key principle: Rhythmic tools help readers tap into character experience viscerally, but they need to be used judiciously so that they don’t overshadow the story.
4. Regulate what the reader knows, and when
When there’s a gap between what’s happening and what the reader understands about it, you create suspense. It’s your chance to make them wait and wonder what’s going to happen – to tease them so that their anticipation builds! And all the while, tension increases.
If a particular scene has important information or a surprise in it, even a small one, look for line editing opportunities to delay the reveal by a line or two. If you have several revelations in your scene, think about how you can break them up so they land in stages. Example
In the example above, the tension builds as Marv grapples with his conundrum, and the reader isn’t any the wiser. We uncover the reveal at the same time as him.
I’ve kept that reveal short, concrete and slightly incomplete to maximize impact. This means the reader has to do some of the work in that moment. Further revelation and explanation can come later. 5. Control narrative point of view
What the reader knows, or doesn’t know, is key, so review the scene to check that you’ve reinforced the limits of your chosen narrative point-of-view style.
If you’ve used a limited or subjective viewpoint, which is common in crime fiction and thrillers, check that:
Examples (Arjun is the perspective character)
In the first example, Arjun can’t know that a person is behind him, never mind one holding a gun, precisely because this action is happening behind him. In the revised version, he senses movement, but that’s all. The reader knows only what the character knows, and if Arjun’s uncertain, so are we. That delay in information adds to the tension. Key principle: Limit the information reported in the narrative to what the perspective character can experience. 6. Strengthen your verbs
If you want to maximise tension, looking at your verbs is a great place to start. Small tweaks can make a big difference to whether an action feels like it’s gentler and happening at arm’s length, or strong and immediate.
Generally speaking, weak verbs dilute tension, while stronger ones amplify it, so line edit in a way that focuses the reader’s attention sharply on what’s being done. Example Imagine an escape scene and take a look at the following two options:
Nothing’s technically wrong with the first version, but the action feels expository. Note the verb – ‘was running’. It’s the past continuous tense, or action in progress. That’s grammatically unproblematic but it’s somewhat soft. This is exacerbated by the addition of a clause that reminds the reader what they already know given that this is an escape scene. The second version seeks to draw the reader into the moment. I’ve suggested a more forceful verb – ‘sprinted’. Using the simple past tense conveys urgency. I’ve also replaced the expository ‘trying to get away’ with an additional precise verb – ‘skidded’. Now we leave the reader to join up the dots, and instead of telling them what the intention is – to escape – we focus on what the character’s doing right now. It’s a small change, but one that transforms the energy in the scene and makes it feel more tense. Key principle: If a verb has scaffolding around it – ‘was [verb]ing’, ‘began to [verb]’, ‘seemed to [verb]’ – experiment with stripping it down so it’s more precise and conveys a sense of impact rather than effort. 7. Sharpen dialogue with subtext
Real-life speech is often filled with stuff that comes out of social norms (eg saying hello and goodbye, offering drinks, talking about the weather).
However, including this in your crime fiction or thriller risks ripping the tension out of a scene because it’s not what the reader’s interested in. When you’re line editing, look for opportunities to:
Example: Authentic but distracting
Example: Focused and tension-filled
The first version feels real enough, but it's rather expository. There’s no tension between the two speakers.
In the second version, the filler is gone, and one of the characters is cagey, then interruptive when their colleague goes on the defence. The subtext – that one of them missed something – is shown rather than told. Key principle: Dialogue should do triple duty – reveal character (voice), show the mood (the subtext of the conversation), and deliver intent (so that the story advances). 8. Ensure description matches the stakes
Line editing is also the time to consider whether the stakes in a scene are apparent. The reader should never forget what’s at risk, so check that characters’ actions and reactions match the situation.
Examples of high stakes could include:
In these situations, line edit to ensure your description is targeted and precise. That way, the information conveyed is vivid but delivered fast, creating more immediate pressure-based tension. Examples of low stakes could include:
In these situations, the description can be more detailed and the pace slower. You can still deliver tension, but it’s more stretched out because there’s no imminent threat. Examples
In the high-stakes example, the description is more focused on the immediate movement, which inflates a sense of urgency. Here, the prose creates a mood that’s abrupt and determined. In the low-stakes example, the character is able to move in a more procedural fashion, and take in their surroundings and notice the details. Here, the prose describes a drab, neglected space, and creates a bleak and institutional mood. Key principle: Ensure the level of detail given to the reader reflects the character’s ability to process it in any given situation. 9. Review your story beginnings and chapter endings
A super first line in a novel makes readers ask questions and creates a sense of intrigue that draws the reader in. Think of it as a tension pull.
A powerful closing line in a chapter withholds just enough resolution or adds a twist, which creates momentum. This is the tension push – the encouragement to turn the page and read the next chapter. Examples: Opening lines that pull readers into a novel
Those four novel opening lines provide mystery, imbalance and unanswered implication. Rather than explaining, they disturb the equilibrium and force the reader to ask questions. Examples: Closing lines that push readers onto the next chapter
Those four chapter closing lines function as momentum triggers. Each one either opens a new question, shifts the reader’s perception or interrupts their certainty. Key principle: Start the book with something that disrupts normal expectations of situation, logic or truth. End a chapter at a moment where certainty shifts. Summing up
Every story needs to have a great plot – a structured sequence of events where characters pursue goals, face obstacles and experience change through conflict and resolution. Getting that right is structural or developmental editing work – the shaping stage.
But every novel needs to work at line level too, because that expression work is what will keep readers interested and focused, rather than skimming. Related resources
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to compress your thrillers and crime fiction writing with strong verbs that convey motion, emotion and pace.
What is a verb?
A verb is a word that describes an action or a state of being. For example:
Strong and weak verbs
There are different ways of classifying verbs from a grammatical point of view, but this article uses the terms ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ to describe stylistic impact.
Strong verbs Strong verbs carry the action all by themselves without needing help from other words to make the sentence convey energy and momentum. A precise, vivid verb can replace a string of modifiers. It makes a line faster and sharper, and can trigger a sense of immediacy, danger, tension or suspense in the reader. Weak verbs Weak verbs are vaguer or more generalized, and often rely on help from additional description to explain the action. They tend to slow the pace down. There’s room for both There’s no such thing as ‘wrong’ or ‘right’ when it comes to writing. Strong and weak verbs both have their place. Instead, the writer can make a choice based on the mood they want to create in the scene and how they want the reader to feel in that moment. A comparison of strong and weak verbs
Take a look at the following comparative examples of phrases. They show how a carefully placed strong verb can show rather than tell us something. For example:
In the first sentence, there’s a verbal phrase in play – ‘tried to pull open’. Those four words create a distance between the character and what they’re doing. We focus on the ‘trying’ rather than on the connection between the character’s hands and the drawer. The pace feels gentler, slower, less immediate.
By replacing that verbal phrase with a single strong verb – ‘yanked’ – the action is more immediate. But there’s emotion being conveyed in that action too:
And those emotional undercurrents imply that the character is under pressure, perhaps feeling frustrated, angry or fearful (depending on the scene’s context). In other words, the stronger verb shows the character’s effort through action rather than explanation.
Create immediacy by adjusting filler verbs
Look out for filler verbs in your crime and thriller writing. These act more like padding than action, and sit in the sentence without contributing much.
Common examples include: was, were, seemed, appeared, began, trying and started. These constructions add extra words without adding tension. Writers can create momentum in action scenes by making just small alterations. Here, we’re not talking about changing the verb to a different one, but modifying what we’ve got. Take a look at these examples:
In each of the three pairs above, removal of the filler verb in favour of a tighter revision makes the action feel as if it’s happening now. For the reader, that’s a more immersive experience.
Create impact by interrogating adverbs
Sometimes a writer will use adverbs to intensify the emotion or tension in a sentence.
Adverbs are words that describe or modify verbs (in the same way that adjectives describe or modify nouns). In these next examples, most of the verbs are weak, and it’s the adverb that’s doing the heavy lifting.
I’d never suggest obliterating every single adverb or adverbial phrase from a piece of prose – regardless of what genre the author’s writing in – but I do think robust editing requires us to consider whether those adverbs are creating momentum and energy.
This is particularly important in dramatic scenes, of which there are often plenty in crime fiction, mysteries and thrillers. We want the reader in the moment with the perspective character’s movement, not fighting with the words that describe it. Since the verb is where the action actually happens, it makes sense to interrogate whether readers are being distracted from it. In the examples above, the writer has the opportunity to consider whether a stronger verb might offer precision that shows what the adverb is telling – which means they can ditch the adverb. Here’s what that revision might look like when we use stronger verbs that combine movement and emotion:
Now the sentences are tighter and more engaging.
Making movement thrilling with strong verbs
Crime fiction and thrillers rely on movement – there might be pursuits, fights, discoveries and escapes. And in all those cases, verbs need to carry that movement in a way that captures emotion.
Instead of weaker neutral verbs like went, looked or moved, think about whether verbs that imply force, violence, emotional state or speed might be more effective. Compare the following:
Careful choices allow writers (or their editors) to capture an entire mood in a single verb.
Practise control with a verb-intensity ladder
One way to hone your verb-choosing skills is to build intensity ladders. These help you see how different words, which mean a similar thing, affect the emotional intensity and urgency of a scene.
To be clear, this isn’t about ranking verbs in order of what’s right or wrong or good or bad, but about controlling the impact you want to have on the reader. Here’s an example where the intensity level moves from calm to extreme. The action we’re considering involves the opening of a door.
Door-opening intensity ladder
Here’s another example. This time the action involves the act of moving away from a situation.
Moving-away intensity ladder
When you pick verbs that are lower in intensity, the tension will be quieter and the pace slower. When you choose verbs that are higher in intensity, the tension will be more acute and the pace faster.
What works best in any particular scene will depend on the context, but the point is that just one verb helps you turn up or turn down the dial and control motion, emotion and pace. A tip for editing verbs
If you’re a writer who’s self-editing, or a professional editor providing support for an author, try this exercise. Ask yourself:
Summing up
When looking at word choices in crime fiction and thriller writing, think about which verbs act as controlled triggers for motion, emotion and pace.
The power lies in choosing something that already carries the meaning, because then there’s no need to add adverbials and filler. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
If you’re a UK-based freelance editor or proofreader who still hasn’t decided how to deal with Making Tax Digital, here’s how one of your colleagues solved the problem by using a bridging service.
In this post ...
A caveat
I’m a professional editorial business owner, not a tax expert. The information I’ve provided below is what I’ve picked up on my MTD journey, and I've done my best to ensure it’s correct at the time of writing (April 2026).
If you’re in any doubt about your own tax position, speak to an accountant. There’s lots of information at GOV.UK too. What is Making Tax Digital?
Making Tax Digital (MTD) is the UK government’s attempt to drag tax reporting out of spreadsheets and shoeboxes and into the twenty-first century.
MTD means we, as UK-based sole traders, have to keep digital records and file updates using compatible software several times a year. The idea is to make things more accurate, reduce errors and cut down on last-minute annual panics. Personally, I wasn’t panicked by the traditional system. And I was more than happy managing my finances in a spreadsheet … And with submitting my tax return via HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC)’s online self-assessment gateway … And with doing that just once a year … And at zero cost to me. I’m starting to sound like a grouch, but I promise I’ll be sharing the low-cost solution I found below! When does MTD start?
MTD is already up and running for self-employed people who are earning over a particular income threshold. Those who don’t meet that threshold will have a year’s grace.
Still, you might qualify to join the scheme early, and that could be a good option for anyone wanting to get to grips with it ahead of time so there’s no last-minute rush. How often do we have to file with MTD?
With MTD we have to submit what HMRC calls quarterly updates.
The key thing we all need to bear in mind is that these updates are cumulative. We’re not doing four separate mini-returns. Think of it as a rolling picture that builds across the year. If your financial year starts on 6 April, the deadlines will be as follows:
At the end of the year, there's an End of Period Statement (EOPS) that, says HMRC, ‘confirms the figures for the full year and allows accounting adjustments such as capital allowances or basis period adjustments’. Then there’s the final declaration (which replaces the self-assessment tax return), and that’s due by 31 January following the end of the tax year. What all this means is that there are way more touchpoints but no change to when your financial year starts or when the final bill gets sorted. What is a bridging service?
Given that I was already perfectly happy with using a spreadsheet, then submitting my tax returns digitally, and not spending a bean in the process, I absolutely didn’t want to fork out for an accountant four times a year or expensive software.
For that reason, last year I started exploring affordable bridging services. A bridging service for MTD acts a bit like a translator between your existing records and HMRC’s systems. If, like me, you’re still recording your income and expenses in spreadsheets, those spreadsheets aren’t set up to talk directly to HMRC. That’s where bridging software comes in. It bridges the gap by taking the figures from your spreadsheet and submitting them to HMRC in the right digital format. And that allows you to stay compliant with MTD without ditching the way you already work. In practice, it means:
So, if you’re happy with spreadsheets, like I am, and don’t want to move to full accounting services just yet (or ever!), a bridging service can be a handy halfway house. Why I chose 123sheets
My research led me to sign up with 123sheets. Here's why I chose them:
To be clear, there’s no financial benefit for me by telling you about this company. I’m simply sharing the choice I made with you, and the reasons behind it, so that anyone who’s feeling a bit flummoxed, and who’s a spreadsheet user like me, might feel a bit more reassured that there are user-friendly options out there. There’ll be plenty of other UK-based professionals in our industry who've already opted (or will opt) for other methods with different providers. Preparation tips for using bridging services
Here are some tips to help you prepare if you decide to go down the bridging-software route.
Choose a good-fit provider
Prep your spreadsheet
Sign up for MTD
Shift your mindset
Wrapping up
Change can be hard for busy business owners, especially when we can’t immediately see how the outcomes benefit us. That’s how MTD is making a lot of self-employed people feel.
However, by getting organised, and selecting tools and providers who can help us keep things ticking over smoothly, I'm confident that MTD can be just another a bit of admin rather than a headache. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to manage scope creep and set healthy boundaries in your editing and proofreading work.
Summary of Episode 154
Listen to find out more about:
Listen to the episodeSupport The Editing Podcast
Music credit
'Vivacity’ by Kevin MacLeod
Explore seven effective types of thriller opening lines, and how published novelists are using them to convince their audiences to keep on reading.
In this article
The recognizable patterns in thriller opening lines
The opening line of a thriller has a difficult job. In a single sentence it must capture attention and convince readers that the story is worth their time.
While great first lines vary in style, there are some recognizable patterns. Understanding these can help writers craft first sentences that hook readers immediately. Below we’ll look at seven types of thriller opening lines – each illustrated with examples from published novels – and examine why they work and what writers can learn from them. What these opening lines have in common
Despite their differences, superb thriller first lines usually share several notable qualities:
1. First-line focus on a pursuit
Some thrillers begin with motion already underway: someone is chasing, escaping or searching.
Example: The Gunslinger, Stephen King (Hodder Paperback edition, 2003)
Why it works
Readers are thrust straight into the middle of a high-stakes chase. In a single line, we sense the tension: one character fleeing, another in pursuit. The sentence immediately conveys motion, suspense and intrigue, and prompts questions like: Who are these figures and what is at stake? NOTABLE QUALITIES: Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Momentum Lesson for writers Movement signals urgency. Starting with that signals that the story is already underway and that the reader has arrived in the middle of something important. 2. First-line focus on psychological mindset
These first lines hook readers by revealing a shocking fact, personal truth or secret. They often feel rather confessional create powerful psychological intrigue because they invite readers into a character’s headspace.
Example 1: Dark Places, Gillian Flynn (Phoenix edition, 2010)
Why it works
The opening plunges readers into the narrator’s psyche, exposing an unsettling inner darkness before any plot events occur. This early insight builds psychological tension, making us question the narrator’s reliability and wonder how their mindset will shape the story. NOTABLE QUALITIES: Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Voice Example 2: The Martian, Andy Weir (Del Rey edition, 2014)
Why it works
In those first four words, the narrator signals that disaster has struck. The candid, no-nonsense tone generates immediate suspense, encouraging readers to ask: What has happened? How will the character cope? NOTABLE QUALITIES: Stakes | Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Voice Lesson for writers Confessional first lines can draw readers directly into a character’s predicament or provide striking psychological insight in just a few words. These two examples are also good reminders that a strong narrative voice can be just as compelling as action or a crime. 3. First-line focus on a shocking statement
A bold or disturbing statement can grab readers immediately, forcing them to confront moral tension or danger.
Example: I Will Find You, Harlan Coben (Penguin edition, 2023)
Why it works
A single, startling sentence conveys both shock and intrigue. It instantly raises questions and emotional stakes. Readers want to understand the circumstances that led the narrator, speaking directly to us, to this moment. NOTABLE QUALITIES: Stakes | Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Voice | Momentum Lesson for writers A single unexpected statement can create a powerful hook if it suggests a deeper story. 5. First-line focus on a crime or transgression
Some thrillers’ opening lines reveal a crime or transgression that has already occurred or is in progress.
Example: Paradise, Toni Morrison (Vintage edition, 1999)
Why it works
The sentence is shocking, violent and blunt, though we’re not given any context. That ambiguity forces readers to ask questions: Who are ‘they’? Who are the other girls that it’s implied are also going to be shot? Why have these girls been targeted? NOTABLE QUALITIES: Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Momentum Lesson for writers Introducing the crime early tells readers exactly what kind of story they’re entering. 6. First-line focus on the environment
Some thrillers begin by establishing an unsettling atmosphere.
Example 1: Neuromancer, William Gibson (Gateway edition, 2016)
Why it works
This line uses a striking image to establish a bleak, dystopian environment. It signals that the world of the story may feel strange or unsettling. NOTABLE QUALITIES: Tension or conflict | Voice Example 2: The Day of the Jackal, Frederick Forsyth (Arrow edition, 2011)
Why it works
This opening sentence starts with information about the weather and the time. It could have been dull, but the author uses it as an artful anchor for the life‑or‑death clause that follows. The stark, cold setting mirrors the flat, cold voice, as if the narrator has accepted the inevitability of the execution. NOTABLE QUALITIES: Stakes | Tension or conflict | Voice Lesson for writers A vivid or unusual image can establish tone while creating curiosity about the setting. And environmental information can be highly effective as long as it’s used to amplify a character’s mood. 7. First-line focus on foreboding
This type of opening signals that something terrible has already happened, or is about to happen.
Example 1: Everybody Knows, Jordan Harper (Faber & Faber edition, 2023)
Why it works
In just three stark words, this first line establishes a vivid, ominous setting that suggests chaos and danger. Something catastrophic is happening in a familiar city, and readers want to know what caused it and what the consequences will be. NOTABLE QUALITIES: Stakes | Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Momentum Example 2: Gone Before Goodbye, Harlan Coben and Reese Witherspoon (Penguin, 2026)
Why it works
In just five words, this line creates immediate tension. By emphasizing what the narrator doesn’t hear, it heightens the sense of unseen danger. The absence of sound signals that something is amiss, prompting readers to ask: What’s happening, and what threat lurks nearby? NOTABLE QUALITIES: Curiosity | Tension or conflict | Momentum Lesson for writers Opening lines that imply catastrophe, danger or abnormality can be incredibly effective. By hinting that something is wrong, rather than explaining it immediately, activate the reader’s curiosity and tension, and compel them to keep going. Summing up
A thriller’s first line doesn’t have to feature explosions or violence. What matters is that it avoids the mundane.
That means encouraging questions and making the reader feel something – for example shock, surprise, disgust, fear, confusion – so that they want to continue beyond the opening sentence and into the rest of the story. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Explore 10 weak thriller opening lines and learn how to turn them into compelling hooks that grab the reader, set the tone and hint at something that piques their curiosity.
The weight carried by the opening line
The opening line of a mystery or thriller carries an enormous amount of weight. In just a few words, it has to hook the reader, set the tone and indicate a problem or predicament that will pique the reader’s interest.
Manuscripts with first lines that feature routine description, backstory or everyday dialogue can feel flat rather than gripping. In this article, we’ll look at 10 examples of weak first lines, explain why they don’t work, and show how small revisions can turn them into compelling hooks. If you’re writing a mystery, crime novel or psychological thriller, these examples will help you craft a first sentence that immediately grabs readers … and keeps them wanting to read. Example 1: Generic description
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
The description is generic and objective. There’s no character, no tension and no intrigue. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
The objectivity remains, but now the reader is immediately introduced to a crime – one that makes us ask questions: Whose body? How did they die? And by whose hand? Example 2: Routine activity
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
While there’s a human being involved in this line, Harris’s actions are mundane. The sentence is front loaded with activity related to where he sits. Even though a murder weapon is mentioned, that’s not particularly interesting given the detective’s job. There’s no reason for us to do anything with this line than skim over it. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now there’s a conundrum for us to consider – the familiarity of the weapon. This creates a pressure point for Harris, and a mystery that readers want an explanation for. Example 3: Focus on backstory
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
The focus here is on the past rather than the present, and that backstory is generalised and mundane. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now there’s momentum. The word ‘first’ introduces foreshadowing – readers will assume that there’s more than one dead body. The mention of proximity to a named character forces us to wonder about her role: Is Martha a potential victim, too, or is she a transgressor? Example 4: No intrigue
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
So what? the reader might think. Waking up early in the morning is not intriguing. It’s commonplace. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now there’s immediate tension. The word ‘someone’ implies that another person entering the house is unexpected. And yet ‘unlocking’ suggests they have a key. That leads to readers asking questions: Who’s in his space? Should they be there? Is John in danger? Example 5: Vague observation
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
This line tells us readers nothing about why they should care about this peaceful place, nor why they should carry on reading about it. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
The revised line is still told from an objective perspective, and the peacefulness has been left intact. However, that information is now sharply juxtaposed with a shocking discovery. Using contrast helps to create surprise and intrigue. Example 6: Dull dialogue
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
This is mundane speech – the kind of thing millions of people say to each other at times and spaces across the entire planet. It won’t compel a reader to continue. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now we have an instant mystery. Readers will wonder what the ‘it’ is that Tom didn’t do, and they’ll want to know why he’s doubting himself. Example 7: Tensionless thoughts
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
There’s no pressure point in this character thought. It’s skimmable information. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now we understand the possible emotional stakes in play. Maybe this information comes as a horrific shock to Emily. Or maybe it will be revealed that she killed him. It actually doesn’t matter. All that’s important is that this is personal, and the reader will be invested in understanding why. Example 8: Boring environment
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
The description feels flat and doesn’t convey any personality or tension. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
Now we have an anonymous narrator with a clear agenda. While the motive is as yet unclear, which creates suspense, the tone is distinctly menacing. Readers will be wondering who this character is and what Flint’s done to evoke such anger. Example 9: Flat impact
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
This at least introduces an interesting premise – that of the return of a missing person. However, it feels a little flat and lacks impact. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
In the revised version, the missing person has a name. And by leading with punchy description of how long Flowers has been missing for, the follow-up clause about her unexpected return creates shock and intrigue. Example 10: No threat
Weak first line
Why it’s ineffective
While the use of a second-person narrative hints at voyeurism, there’s nothing in that line that indicates anything’s out of whack. Suggested improvement
Why the revision helps
The expository information about the mailbox, envelope and photograph are still there, as is the voyeuristic narration. However, by giving readers a small nudge about what’s in that image, there’s an imminent sense of threat. Summing up
A great opening line to any thriller or mystery usually does at least one of these things:
If these aren't evident in your first line, it’s worth revisiting. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn what every thriller must accomplish in its first five pages, including compelling opening lines, early pressure points, clear viewpoint characters and narrative momentum. Discover how to hook readers, build tension and set the stage for a gripping, page-turning story from the very first sentence.
In this article
Why the first 5 pages are a pitch to the reader
Thrillers live or die by their opening pages. We can think of them as a hook or a pitch – the thing that convinces readers to invest in the rest of the novel. This is the space that sets the tone, whets the appetite and sells the idea of what’s to come.
Readers pick up a thriller expecting immediate tension, momentum and intrigue. An editor will be looking for those same qualities too. Here’s what you should look out for when reviewing your first five pages. 1. Is the opening line compelling?
The very first line in a novel sets expectations for the entire story. When it comes to thrillers, readers love hearing a distinctive voice, a sense of movement or tension, and a hint of the predicament or situation a character’s dealing with.
Weak opening lines These often begin with neutral description or background information. For example:
These opening lines struggle because nothing specific or interesting is happening. The information is generic. There are no stakes and no reason for the reader to be curious. Strong opening lines Strong opening lines feature a character in motion or a problem. Harlan Coben is brilliant at writing knock-out opening lines. Take a look at these examples and compare them with the yawn fest above:
Notice how he zooms right in on a problem – rejection, harm, murder. It’s not just that Coben gets to the point. It’s that he injects so much emotion into each of those sentences. He does this by making sure that the psychic distance between the reader and the narrator feels close, like the character is talking to us intimately … There’s oodles of suspense too. Absolutely no way are we putting down any of those books after we’ve read their opening lines because, in just a few words, the author has made us a promise – that having set the scene he will answer the questions we’re already asking:
Tip for writers and editors If the opening line doesn’t pique the reader’s curiosity, or create tension or intrigue, consider a recast. 2. Have you introduced a pressure point?
A thriller's first five pages don’t need to be infused with violence or high-octane action, but they should show the reader where the pressure is.
Weak pressure Review your first few pages and make sure they’re not dominated by the routine and mundane. Waking up, commuting and casual conversations risk making your reader skim. Readers of the genre expect to be thrilled, and if you don’t satisfy that appetite early on, they may disengage and start wondering when the story’s going to pick up. Strong pressure Here’s how authors might could inject pressure points into the early pages of their stories:
Tip for writers and editors Scan the first pages for early conflict or unusual events. Ask yourself this: Is there an indication that something’s already wrong or off? If not, and exposition or a calm setup are dominating, consider how curiosity, danger or high stakes could be introduced. 3. Is a clear point-of-view character present?
When readers can step into a character’s perspective early on, they become engaged faster and more deeply invested in the story.
It doesn’t have to be the protagonist. It could be an anonymous antagonist or transgressor. It could be a victim. The point is that we want to know whose story we’re following in those first few pages. Weak perspectives A thriller whose early pages focus on vague, objective information with no emotional resonance can distance readers. We end up not understanding who we’re supposed to be rooting for or who we want to see stopped. Strong perspectives Readers are people. They know what it is to be human – to love, to fear, to hate, to despair. Compelling opening pages feed that innate knowledge. They provide information that helps us invest in a particular character, even if that emotional investment is negative. We should get an early sense of the following:
Tip for writers and editors Consider whether the first five pages tell readers what the viewpoint character stands to lose, why this situation matters to them and what is motivating them to act? If those personal stakes aren’t shown early on, the prose will feel flat and readers might switch off. 4. Have you created momentum?
Thrillers rely heavily on forward movement throughout, but the opening pages are particularly critical because that’s where writers get their first chance to earn readers’ trust and prove that momentum will be attended to.
Weak momentum The first five pages are not the place for information dumps that provide:
There is definitely a place for all of that stuff, but it’s better to introduce it appropriately after the story has got moving, particularly if it’s detailed. Not doing so means things could end up feeling rather static. Strong momentum Early pages that focus tightly on a problem, a mystery, a decision or an unusual situation will hold readers’ attention. We don’t need to be given all the answers or supporting information at this point – there’s a whole novel to do that. And in fact, not having all the background helps build intrigue and drive curiosity. The opening five pages of TM Logan’s 29 Seconds (Zaffre, 2018) give a superb example of narrative momentum. Readers are offered the following:
Throughout these few pages we’re presented with, first, a mystery, then tension as she tries to manage her shock and fear during the harassment. There are more questions than answers, but Logan makes us wait, concentrating on momentum rather than filling in all the detail. Tip for writers and editors Focus on motion rather than explanations in the first five pages. That energy will ensure that readers are prepared to wait for the detail that fills in all the gaps. Summing up
The first five pages of a thriller should do four things:
When those elements are in place, readers will want to turn pages 6, 7 and beyond. About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn about why character names matter, how to approach the ‘hard-to-pronounce’ issue, and practical strategies for making your characters memorable, readable and believable.
In this article
Why character names are more than just labels
The name you choose for a character is a vital part of storytelling. A well-chosen name can signal personality, social background, culture or even foreshadow events in your story.
On the other hand, confusing, repetitive or inconsistent names can pull readers out of the narrative, making them struggle to remember your characters or follow the plot. In this article, we’ll explore why character names matter, how to approach the ‘hard-to-pronounce’ issue, and look at some practical strategies for making your characters memorable, readable and believable. Why names matter
A character’s name is often the first thing a reader learns about them. It can:
For example, in one of Jeff Carson’s series, the protagonist is called ‘David Wolf’. This evokes a certain intelligence, strength and cunning that blends familiarity with a primal, instinctive edge. In Chris Brookmyre’s Places of Darkness – a novel set in the future and on a vast space station orbiting earth – the cynical security officer entangled in organized crime is called Nikki Freeman. The first name feels casual and friendly, while the last name suggests autonomy, resilience and someone unbound by convention or authority. Consider also these two examples from Philip K Dick novels:
Dick’s names often balance familiarity with eccentricity, helping readers navigate surreal, speculative worlds while subtly suggesting character traits or thematic resonance. Beyond meaning, names help readers track characters across scenes. In novels with large casts and complex plots, distinct names prevent confusion. Embracing diversity in character naming
Today’s literary landscape is global, and character names reflect that. A name might be culturally or regionally specific, and can reflect both real-world multiculturalism and the inventive worlds of speculative crime and mystery fiction.
Speculative fiction, fantasy, science fiction and other world-building genres have long embraced invented names to convey a sense of otherworldliness or cultural specificity. In crime fiction, mystery and thrillers, readers are also increasingly encountering names from cultures and regions that they may not be familiar with. Regional branches of the noir tradition in particular – French, Tartan, Nordic, Afro, Asian – are rich and popular, and explore human weakness, moral uncertainty and the darker side of society. With that, we get characters who have authentic names, the pronunciation of which may not at first sight be obvious to some readers: Examples include:
‘Hard-to-pronounce’ names
When thinking the challenges of pronunciation, we need to start with a question: Hard to pronounce for whom?
When we say that a name’s hard to pronounce, we have to recognize that all we’re doing is reflecting our own personal perceptions and language abilities. There is no such thing as a universally ‘hard-to-pronounce’ name. What I – as a white, British person who’s something of a monoglot and not nearly as well travelled as I’d like to be – might find hard to pronounce is not what someone else might struggle with. Consider the examples I gave above – Mma Precious Ramotswe, Keita Mori, Kacper Ryx, Sartaj Singh and Ganesh Gaitonde. Those with a more intimate knowledge of life in Botswana, Japan, Poland and India would not need help pronouncing those character names in the way I would. The answer isn’t to choose alternative names and rip the authenticity from the novel in service of Western European or North American readers' comfort zones. Instead, authors wanting to help out their audience and maximise engagement can take various steps … Helping readers with pronunciation
It’s great to see diversity in the genre because this reflects the diversity in the readership base. Authors, however, do have to recognize that naming characters in ways that are universally accessible (at least on first read) is an impossible task.
That diversity will necessarily introduce challenges for some, and names that feel unfamiliar could trip them up and cause disengagement, no matter how brilliant the plot. The solution is to offer gentle cues that feel natural to the story, rather than forcing explanations on readers. That way, authors can maintain the narrative flow while helping readers engage. Some strategies could include: Phonetic hints in dialogue Show characters correcting pronunciation naturally. For example:
That’s the approach Pulley takes in The Watchmaker of Filigree Street to help readers pronounce Keita Mori’s name.
Contextual clues You could use other characters’ reactions or narrative descriptions to reinforce pronunciation subtly. For example, a viewpoint character’s narrative might go as follows:
Glossaries or appendices
It’s not uncommon in fantasy and science fiction to include glossaries that list pronunciation alongside character names, locations and worldbuilding terms. This can be an option for crime and thriller writers too. Helping readers with naming conventions
Some readers may be unfamiliar with naming conventions in other parts of the world. These can signal:
Example In Jar City, Arnaldur Indriðason's detective and criminal characters refer to each other by first name, which reflects the patronymic naming convention in Iceland and how first names don't always indicate social intimacy. Explaining to readers Crime and thriller writers can follow Indriðason's approach by including an explanatory note for readers in the front matter of the book. This helps the audience understand social nuance, hierarchy and cultural authenticity, which are especially important in novels where status matters. Names as character signposts
Names can also act as subtle character signposts. They can hint at personality, social standing or plot function.
Balancing uniqueness with readability
The trick is finding the sweet spot between authenticity, uniqueness and readability. Here are two practical tips:
Distinctiveness Distinctiveness is particularly important in crime fiction, mysteries and thrillers so that readers don’t end up confusing suspects, detectives and witnesses.
Pronounceable structure Names should be speakable, even if that means helping your reader learn how to speak them (as discussed above). The role of nicknames and titles
A carefully applied nickname or title can prevent confusion while reinforcing personality or status, especially in ensemble casts.
Nicknames These can make characters more approachable or signal relationships. One of my authors, whose characters were Polish, took this approach and it was very effective. A police officer with the last name ‘Cherniawski’ was often referred to in narrative and dialogue as Cheri, when it was appropriate to do so. As well as signalling intimacy between characters, it also helped Western European and North American audiences shift their attention away from pronunciation and towards character action. Titles or ranks These are especially useful in crime, military or political fiction, for example ‘Detective Rivera’ or ‘Captain Leong’. Aliases These can add mystery or misdirection, particularly in thrillers and espionage. Testing names in context
Before finalizing names, test them to make sure they work.
Read them aloud Reading aloud is a valuable exercise in crime fiction and thrillers, where names will appear frequently in dialogue, police reports and investigative notes. A character’s name should flow within the prose rather than interrupting it. Ask beta readers Can they pronounce the characters’ names easily? If they’re struggling, but you’re committed to retaining the name for the purpose of authenticity, check whether there are cues you can introduce to help readers learn quickly. Check context Do the names you’ve chosen fit within the cultural or regional context of the novel? Two common pitfalls to watch out for
When naming characters, watch out for:
1. Unintentional associations You may have created characters whose heritage is different from your own. Do some research to ensure that your characters’ names don’t inadvertently evoke real people, brands or stereotypes, particularly if those conflict with the character’s persona. For example, unless you’re writing satirical crime fiction, it won’t make sense to call a lazy, overweight investigator ‘Venus Williams’. The reader will all too frequently end up thinking of an athletic superstar, and your characterization will be undermined. Google Search is your friend here. 2. Inconsistency (especially across series) Check that characters’ names are spelled consistently and that their titles are consistent. Ms Abi Starling shouldn’t become Miss Abby Sterling. Maintaining a character list or spreadsheet with name spellings, nicknames and relationships can help you keep track of consistency, especially if you’re writing a book series. A handy little tool you can use for this purpose, if you’re working in Word, is a macro called ProperNounAlyse. Summing up
A character’s name is one of the first things a reader encounters, and it often lingers long after the story ends. Thoughtfully chosen names improve clarity, reinforce characterization and deepen immersion.
Even hard-to-pronounce or culturally specific names can work beautifully when authors provide cues, context and consistency. In short, the best names are:
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Before you send your manuscript to an agent, editor or beta reader, use this comprehensive 10-step checklist to ensure your story is as tight, compelling and credible as possible.
Why self-editing is part of the writing process
A loose end, unconvincing motive, lack of tension and suspense, or mistimed reveal can unravel an otherwise gripping story. For that reason, self-editing is more than just a final step. Instead, think of it as a critical part of your writing craft process.
Check #1: Plot and structure: Does the mystery hold up?
Start with the backbone of your story: the plot.
Strong crime fiction and thrillers typically follow a clear trajectory – setup, investigation, escalation and resolution. That doesn’t mean the novel has to be predictable, but the reader does need to be able to see the logic in the events as they unfold. In particular, ask yourself whether there any coincidences that solve too problems conveniently. It’s important that any key twists feel earned, rather than shoehorned in to make the story work. Pay special attention to your ending. A satisfying resolution should feel both surprising and inevitable. TIP: One useful technique is to work backwards from the reveal. Does every major plot point support that conclusion? Check #2: Clues and red herrings: Are you playing fair?
Crime, mystery and thriller readers love trying to solve the puzzle alongside the protagonist. That means you need to play fair.
Every crucial clue should have been planted before the reveal. That means finding a balance between keeping those clues obscure but not completely hidden. not hidden, but not obvious either. As for red herrings, these need to mislead without feeling manipulative or obvious. If readers feel they’ve been tricked rather than challenged, the story loses credibility. The Golden Age writers were particularly adept at this, making sure that all the pieces are there and, ultimately, fit together. TIP: Ask yourself whether an attentive reader could solve this mystery well before the ending? Check #3: Character behaviour: Is it consistent and logical?
In this genre, the transgressive behaviour hinges on human behaviour – the characters’ motives, opportunities and psychology.
Consistency doesn’t require that a character can’t change. They can, and in that case that change will be key to the story’s arc. However, that change needs to make sense for the reader and driven in a way that’s clear to them. Review each major character and check that:
TIP: Pay special attention to your antagonist. Their actions must make sense within the logic of the story. A brilliant twist won’t land well if the character behind it feels underdeveloped or inconsistent. Check #4: Character names: Are they distinct?
Confusion is the enemy of tight crime and thriller writing. And nothing’s more confusing that when characters have the same names.
Of course, that’s something we experience in everyday life, but when it comes to novel writing, readers need to be able to identify who’s who. That becomes even more important when you’re writing a series because to ensure continuity, there’ll be no going back! Make sure that:
TIP: Create a simple character list or spreadsheet to track names, titles, appearances, traits and relationships. Check #5: Timeline and continuity: Does everything add up?
Crime, mystery and thrillers often involve intricate timelines – alibis, movements, sequences of events. This is where many drafts fall apart.
Comb your draft manuscript and check the following:
TIP: Creating a separate timeline document can make this job easier. List exactly where each character is at every key moment. If something doesn’t line up there, it won’t line up for your reader either. Check #6: Procedure: Is it plausible but engaging?
You don’t need to be a forensic expert to write in this genre, but your story does need to feel plausible, even if the setting is speculative.
Chris Brookmyre’s Places in the Darkness is a superb example. It follows a murder investigation on a near-future space station, where politics, class and human behaviour drive the mystery. Despite the speculative setting, it feels plausible because the crime – and its motives – are grounded in recognisably human conflicts. Bear in mind that fiction can become dull if it mirrors real investigations too closely – lots of details about paperwork, delays and routine steps can drain tension and suspense. Check the following:
TIP: Prioritise tension over total realism. Include only the procedural details that increase the stakes, help the reader make sense of the investigation or reveal a character more deeply. Check #7: Is the dialogue engaging and purposeful?
Dialogue is one of the most powerful tools for building tension and revealing character.
When a character’s speech focuses too much on everyday but mundane information – like discussions about the weather or how people take their coffee – readers can become bored, even though what’s being said would happen in real life. As you edit:
TIP: Read your dialogue aloud. If it feels awkward to say, it’ll feel awkward to read. Check #8: Pacing and suspense: Do they keep readers hooked?
Crime, mysteries and thrillers need to pull readers forward relentlessly.
Each scene should either advance the plot, deepen character or increase tension – ideally all three. If it doesn’t, consider cutting or rewriting it. Look out for:
TIP: End every chapter with a question or unresolved tension. This article has 7 suggestions that will help you do that at line level. Check #9: Point of view: Are the shifts in perspective clear?
When readers have access to what’s going on in every character’s head in a single scene, head-hopping might be in play.
That can rip tension and suspense from your novel because readers know what everyone’s thinking and feeling. Nothing’s withheld. More crucially, perhaps, it stops them investing in a character’s experience in the moment. The psychic distance widens and makes them feel like they’re a distant observer rather than a participant. Of course, it’s fine to have more than one viewpoint character, but check that:
TIP: Highlight every sentence in which there’s information that your POV character couldn’t directly perceive or know. If anything slips through (another character’s thoughts, unseen actions), you’ve broken viewpoint, and it’s time to revise so everything is filtered strictly through that character’s experience. Check #10: Line craft: Is your writing sharp?
Effective line craft sharpens prose by making every sentence purposeful, precise and engaging. When we line edit, we’re seeking to enhance clarity, tone and rhythm and to eliminate excess.
That way the story flows smoothly and keeps readers immersed. Zoom in on your narrative and focus on the following:
TIP: Trust your readers, then cut unnecessary words. If a word, phrase or sentence doesn’t reveal character, advance the plot or heighten tension, remove it. Summing up
Robust self-editing will mean your draft is in the best shape possible before it goes to someone else. It might feel like a time-consuming thing to do, but it will save you time in the long run, and perhaps even money.
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn about how to use AI tools ethically when editing or proofreading.
Summary of Episode 151
Find out more about the following:
Listen to Episode 151Get the podcast book series
These five guides (available in print or ebook) capture the essence of our conversations on the podcast covering five core themes: editorial foundations, growth, sustainability, legacy and marketing. Buy now from from Amazon or find out more about the series.
Support The Editing Podcast
Music credit
'Vivacity’ by Kevin MacLeod
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to edit more efficiently in Microsoft Word using the Quick Parts tool.
In this article ...
Do you edit in Word?
If you edit Word documents, and find yourself typing the same phrases, inserting standard text blocks or fixing the same formatting issues over and over again, Microsoft Word has a built‑in feature that can help you: Quick Parts.
In this article, we’ll look at what Quick Parts is, why it’s so useful, and how you can start using it today to edit faster and more consistently. Note: I work with the Windows operating system, so the instructions I’ve offered below align with that. What is Quick Parts?
Quick Parts is a Microsoft Word tool that allows you to store reusable pieces of content – such as text, tables, headers and formatted paragraphs – and insert them into your document easily.
You can think of Quick Parts as a personal library of ready‑made content. Once you save something, you can reuse it across documents without retyping or copying and pasting. This tool really comes into its own if:
Why Quick Parts makes editing more efficient
Using Quick Parts can significantly improve both your speed and accuracy when editing documents. Here’s how:
Whether you’re editing novels, reports, proposals, policies or meeting notes, Quick Parts helps you focus on content quality rather than repetitive tasks. Common editing tasks you can streamline with Quick Parts
Quick Parts is especially helpful for content you use frequently, such as:
In a nutshell, if you’ve ever thought, I’ve typed this before, that’s a strong sign it belongs in Quick Parts. How to create a Quick Part in Microsoft Word
Creating a Quick Part is simple and only takes a moment:
METHOD 1 (quickest)
METHOD 2
You can also assign a category to your Quick Part snippet if you wish:
Whichever method you choose, your content is now stored and ready to use whenever you need it.
How to insert a Quick Part while editing
Once you’ve saved Quick Parts, inserting them is quick and easy:
METHOD 1 (quickest)
METHOD 2
Whichever method you use, the content is inserted instantly with all formatting preserved. How to review or edit your Quick Parts
If you need to change the short name you’ve created, do the following:
A new pane will appear:
Tips for naming your Quick Parts
To get the most out of Quick Parts, use short, clear names that are easy to remember. Think also about how you can reduce the chance of the Quick Parts tool triggering an expansion inappropriately.
IN-PRACTICE EXAMPLE I edit crime fiction, thrillers and mysteries, and when I'm using the Comments tool, I like to give my author clear indications of which particular element of the editing process I’m focusing on. I do this quickly by using headings that I've set up as Quick Parts. Underneath a heading, I can then explain the problem and suggested solution. Plus, because the various headings in the comments are consistent, I can easily search for and review them by topic area. That helps me when I'm putting together a more comprehensive analysis in an editorial report. And to avoid the risk of Quick Parts kicking in when I don't want it to, I add a ‘z’ to my short names. Here are four topic-based headings I've set up in the tool:
Don't forget that you can save much larger blocks of formatted text into the Quick Parts too. Quick Parts versus third-party text-expansion tools
You might already be familiar with third-party productivity tools such as TextExpander. These can really shine when you want to use the same snippets across multiple programs – for example, email, web browsers and other applications.
As always, it comes down to your budget, needs and preferences. If you want something specifically for Word‑centric editing and formatting, consider the following:
If a separate tool would offer you more rounded support and you have the budget for it, that’s fine. You might even decide to use both in your editorial practice. Summing up
If you already edit extensively in Microsoft Word, the Quick Parts tool will help you reduce repetition, save time, maintain consistency and focus on what really matters: delivering clear, high‑quality content to your client.
And you won’t have to spend a penny more because it’s already part of Word! About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Here are 8 suggestions for you to consider when disclosing how you use AI in your editing business.
In this post
Read on to find out more about:
The impact of AI on editors and proofreaders
Editors and proofreaders are already feeling the effects of AI-assisted technologies on their work.
Why disclosure is important
Making time to understand whether AI is part of our editorial workflow because of the digital tools we use, and then disclosing that usage, ensures we model transparency for our clients and our community.
And when we do it, others feel inspired to do the same. That helps everyone make informed decisions based on the best information we have available at the moment. Being transparent also means we’re participating in a journey that fosters professional integrity and trust. Clients are more likely to feel confident in our recommendations when they see us being honest and understand which tools we’re using, why, and what the limitations and risks are. Perhaps, like me, your approach to disclosure is a work in progress, but I think we should all be accepting of that given how rapidly the landscape around us is changing, and how complex some of the issues are! Where to disclose your AI use
There’s no single best place. It’s up to you where you make your disclosure and how you link to it.
I work solely with indie authors and so I’ve chosen to include a section in the terms and conditions that make up my contract of services agreement. That’s because this is the text that clients are required to read prior to making a booking. However, some of you might prefer to create a separate disclosure page and link to it from the T&Cs or your contracts. If modelling transparency is important to you, it’s less about where your disclosure is than that it exists in the first place. What to include in your disclosure
I’ve suggested 8 things to consider for inclusion in your disclosure, though admittedly these are based on my particular needs.
If I’ve omitted anything that you think would be critical to your editorial business, please do leave a comment! Tip 1. Why you use digital tools
This is an opportunity to state at the outset not just that you are using digital tools – and most of us are using them, though not all of them are AI-assisted – but also why.
It shows clients that you’re able to use technology responsibly, and that the goal is to maintain professional standards for their benefit. Example from my T&Cs
To support the quality, accuracy, consistency and efficiency of my editorial work, I use digital tools. Some may contain AI-assisted features or connected services even where I'm not actively using those features.
Reason
I want to clients to know that I’m not working in the Stone Age, and that my use of digital tools will help give them a better result. Tip 2. Who’s accountable for the output
This is an opportunity to make it clear that regardless of a machine’s involvement in your editing process, it’s you, the editor, who’s accountable and responsible for what’s delivered.
Here you’re focusing on your human value – the sense and sensibility you bring to your work for them, even though you’re using tools to help with some of the mundane heavy-lifting. Example from my T&Cs
All outputs are reviewed and refined by me, a qualified human editor, before delivery to ensure quality and contextual accuracy. Software and AI tools are used strictly to support my human editing process and do not replace my human judgement or professional oversight.
Reason
I want to draw attention to the fact that a human is in control of the process at all times. Tip 3. Your use of generative AI in the editing process
Here’s where you can make a clear statement about your specific use of generative AI. It can help to clarify this because not all AI is the same.
Some editors use AI-assisted tools such as ChatGPT, Draftsmith or ProWritingAid for generative support with revisions; some might not. Being transparent helps clients understand what your particular skills are and who or what is doing the work. Example from my T&Cs
Reason
I pride myself on my stylistic line editing skills and want clients to know that I, a human editor, have the capability to do this nuanced and emotional work. Tip 4. Which specific digital tools you use
This is where you can name the digital tools you use as part of your workflow, their specific purpose and whether they’re licenced.
You don’t have to limit yourself to AI-assisted technologies. You can include word-processing and spreadsheet software, PDF tools, consistency checkers, macros, search engines and file management tools associated with your editorial process. Including a full list also means that when you seek a client’s consent (see #8 below), they know exactly which tools they’re consenting to the use of. 3 examples from my T&Cs
Reason
I want my clients to see the breadth of digital tools I use to support my service and to understand that I’m not using any old junk off the internet – where required, I have licences from reputable providers. Tip 5. Where the tools are hosted
This is an opportunity to tell clients whether each of your tools is hosted locally, in the cloud or elsewhere. Bear in mind the following:
If you’ve committed not to uploading client material to third-party sites, creating this information is a good way of double checking that you’re not in breach of that commitment. 3 examples from my T&Cs
Reason
By stating where my digital tools are hosted, I hope my clients will trust that I’m handling their data honestly and responsibly, but within the realms of what’s on offer and practical for my business. Tip 6. AI’s presence and interaction
Some of the editing tools we use may have AI operating in the background, and even though we’re not using it, it’s still ‘reading’ text and transmitting data.
This is an opportunity to be honest about that, and for your client to make informed decisions about whether they’re okay with it. Examples from my T&Cs
Reason
Compare the italic text in the above examples. I think it’s really important that I’m up front about the fact that Copilot is still sniffing around in the background when I’m using Microsoft Word, even though I’m not actively using the AI to suggest textual edits. This is especially the case given that I’m not yet ready to turn the function off because I’m still exploring how it might aid efficiency with non-client work that I do in Word. Tip 7. Use of types of AI systems
You can also disclose whether any AI systems you use are open or closed, or generative, or what your position is on this matter.
Providing this information shows clients that you understand the differences and are making responsible decisions. Example from my T&Cs
Reason
I’m still learning about AI, and the list of editorial digital tools I’m using in 2025 may look different in two years’ time. However, I want my clients to be confident that I’m using them in a way that respects their privacy to the best of my ability. Tip 8. Seeking client consent
If your disclosure is part of your T&Cs and contract agreement, seeking consent is an opportunity for informed transparency, legal compliance and professional integrity.
It’s protects you both, and you’re being clear that there’s choice involved here. You’ve chosen to use a set of tools, but they can decide whether they’re okay with that … before the project’s underway rather than halfway into it, when it's too late. Example from my T&Cs
Reason
I want my clients to formally agree that they’re happy for me to use the tools I’ve listed. That way, it’s part of our service agreement from the get-go and avoids misunderstandings. Can I copy your disclosure statement?
What's right for me, my business and my clients may be partially or completely unsuitable for you and yours, so I wouldn't recommend this.
Instead, think about the tips that I and others in our community have offered up for consideration, and then use that information as a jumping-off point ... something to help you craft your own AI and digital tools disclosure statement – one that's perfect for your business. However, if you're a member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP), you can access a free webinar called Policy Foundations for Editorial Professionals. This includes some prompt-based guidelines to help you build your own disclosure. Go to the on-demand area of the knowledge hub to access the webinar and companion pack. Summing up
I hope you've found these tips useful. Creating a transparent digital tools and AI disclosure statement helps all of us professional editors to build trust, demonstrate ethical practice and ensure we're complying with privacy regulations.
It clarifies how our clients' materials are going to be handled, distinguishes our human expertise from automated support, and protects both parties by obtaining informed consent. And, ultimately, by doing this, we're showing our clients that we're professionals who are committed to treating their data and creative work responsibly and securely. Want to take a look at how I've approached the disclosure of digital tools in my terms and conditions? The button below will take you there – scroll down to section 14.
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
Learn how to identify glue words, hedges and qualifiers, and then explore whether they’re adding clarity and enhancing character voice, or cluttering your fiction writing.
In this post ...
Read on to find out more about:
What are glue words, hedge words and qualifiers?
Glue words, hedge words and qualifiers serve different purposes and are used in different contexts, but all relate to how language functions in writing or speech.
The function of glue words The function of glue words is structural. They hold or glue a sentence together. By themselves they add little semantic meaning to a sentence. Examples include:
The function of hedge words
The function of hedge words is modification. They soften or limit the strength of a claim and can introduce uncertainty, speculation, caution or humility. Examples include:
The function of qualifiers The function of qualifiers is limitation. They narrow the meaning of another word such as a noun or adjective, and make a statement more precise. Examples include:
Are glue words, hedges and qualifiers signal of poor writing?
No, glue words, hedges and qualifiers are not signals of poor writing, not when they’re used with purpose.
If you’re reading guidance on using these words, watch out for statements arguing bluntly that they:
Why? Because this kind of prescriptivism can encourage developing writers to rip the heart and soul out of a character’s voice, emotions and layered experience. The key is to ensure that every word on the page is working hard for you – whether it’s a glue word, a hedging word, a qualifying word, or some other language marker. Using glue words, hedges and qualifiers with purpose
Instead of eliminating glue, hedging and qualifying words, review your sentences and consider whether these markers are:
How glue words can enhance prose
Let’s look at an example of how glue words can enhance a piece of prose:
This paragraph has multiple glue words including ‘was’, ‘that’, ‘despite’, ‘the’, ‘to’, ‘but’ and ‘and’. Think of them as the cement that holds the prose together, ensuring that the prose maintains a smooth syntactic flow even when internal thought becomes more fragmented or reflective.
But note also the rhythmic tool in play in the final clause – the use of multiple gluing conjunctions (polysyndeton) to show rather than tell Lex’s overwhelm as she looks at the report. Glue words can therefore go beyond their structural function. They can also be used as a literary mechanism to evoke mood and emotion. How hedge words can enhance prose
The example also contains instances of hedging language including ‘might have said’, ‘somewhat’ and ‘might be’.
These hedges reflect Lex’s tentativeness in terms of her dad’s opinion, the prosecutor’s strategy and her own self-judgement about her positivity, and this helps readers understand how she bends towards reflection and uncertainty.
The language also helps the writer convey a more realistic voice that carries nuanced emotional conflict. Lex is trying to be rational but her doubt is intruding. Through this, readers are shown how people rarely speak or think in absolutes. How qualifiers can enhance prose
The qualifiers in the excerpt adjust the meaning of the words they modify to give reads more emotional texture.
Overall, the interplay of glue words, hedges and modifiers creates a narrative tone that avoids the extremes of melodrama or stoicism, and instead takes a middle ground that deepens our understanding of Lex as introspective, thoughtful, quietly resigned and gently self-critical.
Summing up
Glue words, hedge words and qualifiers can be effective writing devices when they’re used with purpose.
Don’t ditch yours without first analysing them so you understand whether they’re working for your prose. If they’re just adding to your word count needlessly, remove or rework them. However, if they’re providing your characters with emotional complexity and intelligence, and enhancing the structure, flow and mood of your sentences, embrace them! Other resources you might like
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
This post explores how to use embedded dialogue snippets and what effect they have on tone, character and flow.
In this post ...
Read on to find out more about:
Capturing speech memory
Dialogue doesn’t only happen in real time. Sometimes a character recalls what was said or what they half-heard, or they mentally echo something that was stated in the past. This is speech memory.
Done well, capturing those moments on the page enhances the reader’s experience. It can affect the mood and flow, and subtly shine a narrative light on one particular character, while still revealing how others interacted verbally with them. What is embedded dialogue?
Embedded dialogue is reported speech or remembered lines that are woven into the narrative. The quotation marks and dialogue tags that we’d expect to see in active, real-time dialogue are omitted. Here's an example that compares the two approaches:
Active dialogue plus narrative:
Dialogue embedded in the narrative:
While the reader gets the same information, the mood is different. The active-dialogue version feels punchier, more immediate. The embedded-dialogue version feels more contemplative.
When to use embedded dialogue
1. To reflect a character’s processing of a memory of speech
A remembered line can reveal emotion or motive without cutting to a flashback or breaking the scene. Here are a couple of embedded-dialogue examples:
Active-dialogue versions might look like this:
Again, neither of these versions – the embedded or active dialogue – are right or wrong. But they do convey a different mood, and the prose flows differently. The active dialogue versions are blunter, terser and highlight different voices. The embedded dialogue is smoother and less tense, and highlights one voice.
2. To keep the focus on the viewpoint character and their present tension Recalling memories of the spoken words can add weight to prose without shifting the spotlight away from the viewpoint character's perspective in the now. Here are two embedded-dialogue examples:
Active-dialogue versions might look like this:
I think the embedded dialogue feels much more grounded in the characters’ immediate conundrums. It's their voice that shines through. The active dialogue, however, even with the pluperfect (past-perfect) speech tags, pulls the reader out of the present and shines a light on other characters' speech.
3. To avoid disruption Long dialogue flashbacks can derail pacing. Embedded snippets allow you to fold the past into present seamlessly. Again, here are two embedded-dialogue examples:
Now let’s turn that into active dialogue:
I think the active-dialogue versions are disruptive because the recalled speech is so lengthy and flips the focus onto the past speakers.
However, in the embedded-dialogue versions, the flow of the narrative captures the past speech but maintains the smooth flow of the prose and keeps the reader’s gaze firmly on the current viewpoint characters. 4. To add variety to how 'remembered' dialogue is displayed Using a mixture of embedded and active dialogue can add variety to how remembered speech is displayed, making it more interesting for the reader. Here's an example that includes both:
Here, the two styles work with each other to capture multiple speaker voices, but in a way that still ensures the first-person narrator's immediate experience remains dominant.
When active dialogue works
Active dialogue is brilliant in the following circumstances:
The difference between embedded dialogue and free indirect speech
Both free indirect speech and embedded dialogue are narrative techniques used to represent characters’ thoughts or speech, but they differ in structure and how much the narrator mediates the character's voice.
Here are two examples:
Example 1. Free indirect speech:
Notice how this feels more subjective. The psychic distance between the reader and the character is very close.
Free indirect speech is all about the viewpoint character and focuses on conveying what’s going on in their head now.
Example 2. Embedded dialogue:
Notice how this feels a little more objective and told because of the expository filter word ‘wondering’ and ‘speech-memory indicator ‘said he’d’. The psychic distance is a little wider in this case, as if the prose is being told by the narrator.
Embedded dialogue is all about the viewpoint character’s recollection; it holds the essence of memory … that something specific was actually said in the past. Neither is right or wrong. Instead, free indirect speech and embedded dialogue serve different purposes, and so one might work better than the other depending on what the author’s trying to achieve. Summing up
Embedded dialogue snippets let you carry the weight of past speech without quoting every line. Use them to deepen character, maintain narrative flow and give your prose a more intimate texture.
When done well, embedded dialogue allows the past to echo through to the present, shaping motive and mood without slowing the action. It’s not just about what was said, but how your viewpoint character remembers it. Other resources you might like
About Louise Harnby
Louise Harnby is a line editor, copyeditor and proofreader who specializes in working with crime, mystery, suspense and thriller writers.
She is an Advanced Professional Member of the Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP) and co-hosts The Editing Podcast.
|
NEWSLETTER
Sign up for The Editorial Letter.
AUTHOR RESOURCES
EDITOR RESOURCES
BOOKS FOR EDITORS AND WRITERS
TRAINING COURSES FOR EDITORS
TESTIMONIALS
'I love the clean impact you've brought to my writing'
Thomas R Weaver 'The voyage through your edits is an intellectual and craft adventure' Dan Flanigan 'I'm a better writer because you edited my book' Rich Leder 'You are by far the best literary editor I've had' Nina Fitzpatrick 'I wholeheartedly recommend her services ... Just don’t hire her when I need her' Jeff Carson 'Sincere thanks for a beautiful and elegant piece of work. First class' JB Turner CATEGORIES
All
ARCHIVES
October 2026
|
|
INFO ABOUT ME
● About Louise ● Portfolio ● Qualifications ● Professional Practice Code ● Media bio and headshots ● Contact |
INFO FOR INDIE AUTHORS
● Editorial services ● Fees and availability ● Why choose Louise? ● Testimonials ● Books ● Free resources ● How my editing process works |
INFO FOR EDITORS
● Training courses and books ● Free resources ● Business help ● The Editing Podcast ● The Editing Blog ● Training login |
|
|
Sign up for my monthly newsletter, The Editorial Letter ➜
|